Comments on: The 2008 “American Idol” Top 24: The Spoilers Were Pretty Much Right On http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on Music News, Reviews, and Gossip on Idolator.com Sat, 26 May 2012 18:17:29 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Barbera Koeck http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-1335082 Barbera Koeck Sat, 31 Jul 2010 06:45:38 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-1335082 My mom and I want to create a blogging site much like this for our website, I stumbled across your internet site trying to find some ideas on the theme along with design. I am taking some coding course while attending college but not confident that I would have the capacity to develop a site such as this one just yet. Did you code this website by yourself or use a qualified? My mom and I want to create a blogging site much like this for our website, I stumbled across your internet site trying to find some ideas on the theme along with design. I am taking some coding course while attending college but not confident that I would have the capacity to develop a site such as this one just yet. Did you code this website by yourself or use a qualified?

]]> By: JedTheMime http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461442 JedTheMime Thu, 14 Feb 2008 08:44:24 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461442 <P>Kyle had Vote For The Worst written all over him. And I think Idol is more interested in getting its credibility back this year than in giving America another water cooler punching bag.</P> Kyle had Vote For The Worst written all over him. And I think Idol is more interested in getting its credibility back this year than in giving America another water cooler punching bag.

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461562 Anonymous Thu, 14 Feb 2008 08:43:39 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461562 <p>After watching this ep of Idol I, like everybody else, was busy pondering the vocal abilities and potential star power of the contestants.</p> <p>When it was over, I listened to a few tracks by Josh Groban (Easily the most talented male vocalist in recent modern pop music IMHO).</p> <p>Hearing a voice like JG makes me wonder why I'd even bother with the next Gayken....he really shows how truly amateur these Idol vocalists are.</p> <p>That said, the 16yo kid from Utah and the 29yo Aussie both stand out as the most talented guys of the group.</p> After watching this ep of Idol I, like everybody else, was busy pondering the vocal abilities and potential star power of the contestants.

When it was over, I listened to a few tracks by Josh Groban (Easily the most talented male vocalist in recent modern pop music IMHO).

Hearing a voice like JG makes me wonder why I’d even bother with the next Gayken….he really shows how truly amateur these Idol vocalists are.

That said, the 16yo kid from Utah and the 29yo Aussie both stand out as the most talented guys of the group.

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461452 Anonymous Thu, 14 Feb 2008 06:58:18 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461452 <p>@<a href="#c4216278">JIM THOME'S SELF-CLEANING OVEN</a>: Sorry holmes, I am with you on the Fergie hate, but Groban's a champ...in the big-vocaled, nausea-inducing arena of all things "Adult Contemporary", at least.</p> <p>If the intention is to find the guy who can best hit all the notes, well, I'll stick with the professional on this one.</p> @JIM THOME’S SELF-CLEANING OVEN: Sorry holmes, I am with you on the Fergie hate, but Groban’s a champ…in the big-vocaled, nausea-inducing arena of all things “Adult Contemporary”, at least.

If the intention is to find the guy who can best hit all the notes, well, I’ll stick with the professional on this one.

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461462 Anonymous Thu, 14 Feb 2008 06:47:08 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461462 <p>@<a href="#c4211524">katie_a_princess</a>: HAAAAAAAAA!!!!</p> @katie_a_princess: HAAAAAAAAA!!!!

]]> By: Hamm Beerger http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461472 Hamm Beerger Thu, 14 Feb 2008 06:41:51 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461472 <p>@<a href="#c4207610">HONEYBFLY</a>: If we're shooting for Josh Groban levels of suck, no wonder this show is in so much trouble.</p> @HONEYBFLY: If we’re shooting for Josh Groban levels of suck, no wonder this show is in so much trouble.

]]> By: musicquizking http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461482 musicquizking Thu, 14 Feb 2008 05:12:23 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461482 <P>Last year I worked at a start-up label called Beverly Martel Music and the Aussie contestant, Michael Johns was signed with us. We actually released his self-titled solo album. I went on iTunes to check out if more people have left comments for his album but it seems like someone took it down. Interesting. By the way he was also in a band called The Rising that was signed to Maverick some years back.</P> <P>Check some info out here: <A href="http://beverlymartelmusic.blogspot.com/">[beverlymartelmusic.blogspot.com]</A></P> Last year I worked at a start-up label called Beverly Martel Music and the Aussie contestant, Michael Johns was signed with us. We actually released his self-titled solo album. I went on iTunes to check out if more people have left comments for his album but it seems like someone took it down. Interesting. By the way he was also in a band called The Rising that was signed to Maverick some years back.

Check some info out here: [beverlymartelmusic.blogspot.com]

]]> By: dog door http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461492 dog door Thu, 14 Feb 2008 05:07:37 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461492 <P>@<A href="http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on#c4210601">extracrispy</A>: don't worry, give him two years and he'll be in Williamsburg playing Soundfix & all over Brooklyn Vegan.</P> @extracrispy: don’t worry, give him two years and he’ll be in Williamsburg playing Soundfix & all over Brooklyn Vegan.

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461502 Anonymous Thu, 14 Feb 2008 04:28:55 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461502 <P>@<A href="http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on#c4210601">extracrispy</A>:</P> <P>He may not be a diva-style belter, but he sure is a diva-style weeper.</P> <P>Sorry for the hating. Happy Valentine's Day.</P> @extracrispy:

He may not be a diva-style belter, but he sure is a diva-style weeper.

Sorry for the hating. Happy Valentine’s Day.

]]> By: katie_a_princess http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461512 katie_a_princess Thu, 14 Feb 2008 04:17:04 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461512 <p>colton v. four eyes was so, so sad. it was like comparing soggy french fries to a flat cup of coke</p> colton v. four eyes was so, so sad. it was like comparing soggy french fries to a flat cup of coke

]]> By: extracrispy http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461522 extracrispy Thu, 14 Feb 2008 03:40:15 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461522 <p>I just can't get over that they cut Josiah. That kid is a self-taught musician who plays keyboards, guitar, bass, and drums. He writes his own lyrics and harmonies. He may not be a diva-style belter, but he sounds so contemporary. It just seems like he has way more potential to be a pop star than any of these people. I'm flabbergasted.</p> <p>OK, I don't care anymore. Whew, glad that passed.</p> I just can’t get over that they cut Josiah. That kid is a self-taught musician who plays keyboards, guitar, bass, and drums. He writes his own lyrics and harmonies. He may not be a diva-style belter, but he sounds so contemporary. It just seems like he has way more potential to be a pop star than any of these people. I’m flabbergasted.

OK, I don’t care anymore. Whew, glad that passed.

]]> By: loudersoft http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461572 loudersoft Thu, 14 Feb 2008 03:04:32 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461572 <p>It seems like the producers and the judges are so bored with the process that they don't know what they actually want any more. I want to be excited about this season, but I'm kinda ehhh.</p> It seems like the producers and the judges are so bored with the process that they don’t know what they actually want any more. I want to be excited about this season, but I’m kinda ehhh.

]]> By: Nicolars http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461532 Nicolars Thu, 14 Feb 2008 02:39:24 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461532 <p>This is the first year where I wasn't impressed by any of the finalists, they're all so bland and underwhelming they make Carrie Underwood look like Wendy O Williams.</p> This is the first year where I wasn’t impressed by any of the finalists, they’re all so bland and underwhelming they make Carrie Underwood look like Wendy O Williams.

]]> By: Lampbane http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461582 Lampbane Thu, 14 Feb 2008 02:36:17 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461582 <P>Maybe the producers wanted Kyle gone because they didn't want another Clay Aiken. You know, someone who didn't win but went one to become a huge success anyway. Ruins the whole system (even though the system was ruined anyway).</P> Maybe the producers wanted Kyle gone because they didn’t want another Clay Aiken. You know, someone who didn’t win but went one to become a huge success anyway. Ruins the whole system (even though the system was ruined anyway).

]]> By: Thierry http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461542 Thierry Thu, 14 Feb 2008 02:34:55 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461542 <p>The Aussie (Michael Johns) also sounded remarkably like...Michael Bolton?</p> The Aussie (Michael Johns) also sounded remarkably like…Michael Bolton?

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/356302/the-2008-american-idol-top-24-the-spoilers-were-pretty-much-right-on/comment-page-1#comment-461552 Anonymous Thu, 14 Feb 2008 01:53:43 +0000 http://d9faa661b6e3c14df757b6119ad8b657#comment-461552 <P>The Aussie has pipes, but he's also got charisma. If Rock Star was still on, I don't think we would've seen him on Idol. I say he definitely makes top three.</P> The Aussie has pipes, but he’s also got charisma. If Rock Star was still on, I don’t think we would’ve seen him on Idol. I say he definitely makes top three.

]]>