Comments on: Jane’s Addiction To Reunite Again, But This Time It’s Sort Of For Real http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real Music News, Reviews, and Gossip on Idolator.com Sat, 26 May 2012 15:35:55 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Chris Molanphy http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-533992 Chris Molanphy Wed, 16 Apr 2008 07:17:30 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-533992 <p>@<a href="#c5222956">Ned Raggett</a>: FTW. Lulz of the day.</p> @Ned Raggett: FTW. Lulz of the day.

]]> By: Ned Raggett http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534002 Ned Raggett Wed, 16 Apr 2008 06:20:34 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534002 <p>@<a href="#c5221190">joshservo</a>: <i>then they went back to eating and/or losing hair.</i></p> <p>I could see Perry eating hair.</p> @joshservo: then they went back to eating and/or losing hair.

I could see Perry eating hair.

]]> By: tigerpop http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534012 tigerpop Wed, 16 Apr 2008 05:35:27 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534012 <p>@<a href="#c5221190">joshservo</a>: But...but...Mountain Battles is good!</p> @joshservo: But…but…Mountain Battles is good!

]]> By: TheContrarian http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534022 TheContrarian Wed, 16 Apr 2008 05:35:06 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534022 @joshservo: My money's on Navarro for the Ultimate Legacy Squandering Douchebag Achievement Award. I fell asleep to cable TV one night and woke up at 4 AM to see him "hosting" the Adult Video Awards in a pair of big-eye sunglasses that were dated on the ZooTV tour. FYI, "Kettle Whistle" was a posthumous odds 'n' sods comp with one or two *new* songs. "Strays" was the lame-ass record of all new material from a handful of ears ago. @joshservo: My money’s on Navarro for the Ultimate Legacy Squandering Douchebag Achievement Award.

I fell asleep to cable TV one night and woke up at 4 AM to see him “hosting” the Adult Video Awards in a pair of big-eye sunglasses that were dated on the ZooTV tour.

FYI, “Kettle Whistle” was a posthumous odds ‘n’ sods comp with one or two *new* songs. “Strays” was the lame-ass record of all new material from a handful of ears ago.

]]> By: joshservo http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534032 joshservo Wed, 16 Apr 2008 05:23:34 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534032 <p>@<a href="#c5220427">MC</a>: Here's why. Because unlike the Pixies reunion, Jane's has been half-assedly re-uniting and breaking up since...Jesus, it feels like since the Edison Canister was invented. The Pixies broke up, stayed broken up, just sort of magically reappeared, and then broke up again.</p> <p>Also, it seems as if Farell and Navarro have been engaged in an equally interminable race to see who can more efficiently squander their legacy and the goodwill of their fans. My vote's for Navarro, with his guyliner and myriad reality shows, but you can never rule out Farell for his dogged instance on putting out the worst music possible.</p> <p>The Pixies, on the other hand, just got kind of tubby and/or bald. They did one new terrible song as opposed to Jane's completely meh "Kettle Whistle," and then they went back to eating and/or losing hair.</p> <p>The more apt analogy would have been the Breeders reunion, which to me is as shrugworthy as this here Jane's re-re-renion.</p> @MC: Here’s why. Because unlike the Pixies reunion, Jane’s has been half-assedly re-uniting and breaking up since…Jesus, it feels like since the Edison Canister was invented. The Pixies broke up, stayed broken up, just sort of magically reappeared, and then broke up again.

Also, it seems as if Farell and Navarro have been engaged in an equally interminable race to see who can more efficiently squander their legacy and the goodwill of their fans. My vote’s for Navarro, with his guyliner and myriad reality shows, but you can never rule out Farell for his dogged instance on putting out the worst music possible.

The Pixies, on the other hand, just got kind of tubby and/or bald. They did one new terrible song as opposed to Jane’s completely meh “Kettle Whistle,” and then they went back to eating and/or losing hair.

The more apt analogy would have been the Breeders reunion, which to me is as shrugworthy as this here Jane’s re-re-renion.

]]> By: MC http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534042 MC Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:53:42 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534042 <P>@<A href="http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real#c5219489">Ned Raggett</A>: Not that I know your opinion on the Pixies reunion, but I've been wondering lately why that reunion = sheer ecstasy, whereas Jane's reunion = shameless money grab. (Other than the car commercial I suppose.)</P> @Ned Raggett: Not that I know your opinion on the Pixies reunion, but I’ve been wondering lately why that reunion = sheer ecstasy, whereas Jane’s reunion = shameless money grab. (Other than the car commercial I suppose.)

]]> By: Dead Air ummm Dead Air http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534052 Dead Air ummm Dead Air Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:38:17 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534052 <P>Now if only we can him to be the ringer again on bass for some live Garbage acts all will be right with 1997....</P> Now if only we can him to be the ringer again on bass for some live Garbage acts all will be right with 1997….

]]> By: Ned Raggett http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534062 Ned Raggett Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:22:56 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534062 <p>@<a href="#c5218575">TheContrarian</a>: Seconded. Eric A was my hero for NOT getting involved in any of the reunions.</p> @TheContrarian: Seconded. Eric A was my hero for NOT getting involved in any of the reunions.

]]> By: tigerpop http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534072 tigerpop Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:01:02 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534072 <p>Martyn LeNoble does not approve.</p> Martyn LeNoble does not approve.

]]> By: TheContrarian http://idolator.com/380413/janes-addiction-to-reunite-again-but-this-time-its-sort-of-for-real/comment-page-1#comment-534082 TheContrarian Wed, 16 Apr 2008 03:44:40 +0000 http://48a16203d1cc2cd94c401c53010f3c14#comment-534082 Thank fucking God it's Eric and not some stupid ringer. Thank fucking God it’s Eric and not some stupid ringer.

]]>