NEW YORK, 11:25 AM, FRI DEC 5 | 10 POSTS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS | tips@idolator.com | SUBMIT A TIP | RSS
idolator's american idolatry

Tinfoil Hat Time: Did The Producers Turn Up David Archuleta's Screaming-Girl Chorus By Accident?


I've had a sneaking suspicion for most of the season that the producers have been sweetening the screeching-girl noises during David Archuleta's performances, or at least enhancing it a bit—blame a childhood spent preferring Guns N' Roses to New Kids On the Block. But! During Archie's second song tonight, I swear I heard some evidence that there was at least a little bit of producer manipulation. Watch the clip above; when you hit the 20-second mark or so, listen to the "crowd noise" that comes in. Does it sound oddly muted, and oddly timed, to you? Especially since it's accompanied by a pit full of stock-still young ladies who should have had their hands set to "sway" during this frenzy-inspiring moment? Maybe I'm just hearing the tongue baths of Randy, Paula, and Simon echoing in my ears, but something just seems a little... off. Ah, the unpredictability of live TV! [Redlasso via MJ]

12:45 AM on Wed May 21 2008
By Maura Johnston
745 views
4 comments

Comments

  • I think you're right..... Damn

  • I don't know - while I'm inclined to believe that this is just another screwup in a season full of them, it might also be that we're hearing screams of a group of girls in the back rows of the NOKIA!!!! Theater.

  • I haven't watched AI in a couple years, but it was pretty obvious to me on both this show, (and shows like "Rockstar") that subtle manipulation of the EQ and Vocal mix was going a long way towards making one singer seem better / worse than another. I absolutely believe it. It would be very simple, and with the right touch, it's just barely noticeable.

  • I could believe it. I mean, why not, why wouldn't they jam on the fake applause button? Like this show really has any integrity to begin with.

Comment on this post

Reply by Email

Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.