Many people find it hard to tell the great from the godawful when it comes to 21st-century mainstream rock. To help figure out which is which, here’s “Corporate Rock Still Sells,” where Al “GovernmentNames” Shipley examines what’s good, bad, and ugly in the world of rock and roll. This time around, he celebrates the return of modern-rock radio to his home city of Baltimore with a look at the newest crop of artists to hit the rock charts, and reveals superproducer Max Martin’s stealth assault on the corporate-rock airwaves.
Early on in the life of this column, I acknowledged one big caveat: I’d be reporting on modern rock radio without having easy access to any such station on my radio dial. I’ve based whole columns on songs that I’ve yet to actually hear on terrestrial radio, like the Flobots’ “Handlebars.” Since the demise of the trailblazing WHFS, the Baltimore/Washington, D.C. rock radio market’s rock outlets have been reduced to the active rock station 98 Rock and the active/modern hybrid (DC101). So the dirty little secret of a lot of my reportage is that it’s come from following the charts, playlists, and streams of modern stations in other markets, which has allowed me to see what modern-rock hits haven’t crossed over to active-leaning stations.
But all that’s changed in recent weeks: Clear Channel has flipped one of its smooth jazz stations to Channel 104.3, Baltimore’s first full-time mainstream alt-rock station in over three years. The station is borrowing its morning show from DC101, and from what little I’ve tuned in to hear so far, the playlist may turn out to lean a little Active like its sister station. But for better or worse, it looks like I finally have somewhere to hear crap like “Handlebars” on my car stereo.
Last time, I focused on the new hits from established acts that are currently dominating the Modern Rock top 10. So in the spirit of new beginnings like that of Channel 104.3–albeit symbolic beginnings that tend to bring the same old shit–I thought I’d take a look at some of the more unfamiliar names that are scoring their first radio hits in the lower reaches of the rock charts. By far my favorite recent debut is “Love Me Dead” by Ludo, which is still crawling slowly upward, currently peaking at No. 19 after nearly three months on the chart. I’m not really sure what this band’s deal is, and I’m hesitant to try and describe the song. So I will instead merely hope that you’re as entertained by the video as I was the first time I stumbled upon it:
Another chart debut that’s been kicking around for about the same amount of time with greater success–currently No. 3 on Mainstream Rock and No. 15 on Modern–is “Addicted” by Saving Abel, a band that seems to be striking the same nauseating balance between nu-grunge sludge and Sunset Strip sleaze as, say, Hinder. Hell, “Addicted” sounds eerily similiar to Hinder’s first hit, “Get Stoned,” which is to say, get ready for these assclowns to become the next big Active Rock dynasty. Safetysuit’s “Someone Like You”, at No. 22 on Modern Rock, likewise fits into a comfortable preexisting radio niche of big, sweeping sub-Coldplay arena balladry, even if it’s a little surprising that the band hails from Oklahoma. And the only odd thing about yet another grungy debut, Another Black Day’s “Wicked Souls,” is that it reached No. 25 on Mainstream Rock while on an independent label, Bieler Bros. (As far as I can tell, the only other acts on either chart that aren’t on a major label or a subsidiary thereof are Nine Inch Nails, who of course are record industry castaways by choice, and Vampire Weekend.)
“They Say” by Scars On Broadway, which recently entered the Mainstream Rock chart and currently stands at No. 27, is a new project by some familiar names, System Of A Down’s Daron Malakian and John Dolmayan. With System currently on an ambiguous hiatus that’s widely speculated to be a permanent breakup, Scars On Broadway is the second offshoot of the band to hit the airwaves, after two successful solo singles by singer Serj Tankian. If things proceed at this pace, we could have another vaguely exciting face-off of ex-bandmates, in the fashion of the dueling Angels & Airwaves and +44 singles that followed the breakup of Blink 182 a couple of years ago. And when bands that weren’t that great to begin with start splintering into seperate projects and competing on the chart, the overall effect tends to bring to mind the tagline from 2004’s Alien vs. Predator: Whoever wins… we lose.
Apocalyptica, the Finnish cello ensemble that became something of a novelty act in the mid-’90s for playing classical covers of Metallica songs several years before string tributes to popular rock acts became a cottage industry unto itself, has gradually become a career band with original material, often collaborating with various hard rock and metal vocalists. And in “I’m Not Jesus” with Slipknot’s Corey Taylor, Apocalyptica have finally broken through with their first big mainstream radio hit, “I’m Not Jesus,” which is currently at No. 9 on Mainstream and No. 26 on Modern. It’s not a bad song, but I really have nothing to say about it other than that it still cracks me up that the singer from Slipknot’s real name, after being known as simply “No. 8″ all those years, turned out to be “Corey.”
By far the most eyebrow-raising new artist on the Modern Rock chart is Carolina Liar, whose “I’m Not Over” is currently at No. 24 and rising. Carolina Liar frontman Chad Wolf is a scraggly Southerner, and his hit fits in nicely alongside other slick, guitar-driven rock radio fodder, but his band boasts a unique pedigree. Somehow, after relocating to Los Angeles, Wolf ended up rubbing elbows with adult-contempo types like Dianne Warren and Celine Dion, before ultimately meeting Euro pop mastermind Max Martin, who assembled a band full of Swedish session musicians for Wolf and put together a debut album:
Martin, once known as the architect of the bombastically synthetic sound of his countless hits for Britney Spears and the Backstreet Boys, has moved toward guitar-driven pop rock like Kelly Clarkson’s “Since U Been Gone” and Pink’s “U + Ur Hand” in recent years with the aid of another songwriter/producer for hire, Lukasz “Dr. Luke” Gottwald. But those songs were recorded by female pop stars, and while many rock fans and critics admitted (sometimes grudgingly) a weakness for their crunchy riffs and shoutalong hooks, rock radio never touched them. So it’s interesting that Martin has finally, yet somewhat stealthily, broken through to one of the few corners of American radio that had previously eluded his Midas touch, and one wonders if Wolf was deliberately recruited for just that purpose. Even if that’s not the case, it’s still pretty funny to imagine that back when Martin was ruling the world with hits like “I Want It That Way,” he may have been fantasizing about having his very own Days Of The New.


That Carolina Liar song is getting a lot of play here in LA on Indie 103.1. So much so that I picked up the cd. Its ok, nothing special. Some of the songs give me a Killers-feel, which is fine. Good summer listening I guess, but nothing special.
@Chris Molanphy: One factor you have to take in consideration is that most modern rock stations these days feature a LOT of older classics and recent ‘recurrents’ in their playlists, it’s not like urban radio where it’s new stuff almost all the time. Sometimes I can go an hour without hearing anything from after 2003. So if the stations like that go from playing 2 current songs an hour to 4 or 5 for whatever reason (like, say, a bunch of bands of Coldplay or Weezer’s stature releasing new singles around the same time), it can completely warp the relative airplay counts.
I wonder what Clear Channel’s strategy is here. Won’t they be taking listeners away from their own DC101 with a station like this?
If I’m reading the latest Arbitron ratings correctly, that Smooth Jazz station was #8 in the market (compared to CBS’ WHFS being #14 and DC101 #19)…
@owenmeany: Yeah, I don’t totally get it either, I don’t know what this station’s odds are in the long run. The strangest part is that, although they’re using Elliot In The Morning, the daytime music programming doesn’t seem to have much in the way of DJs/hosts, going for generic Jack FM-style announcer segues and station IDs, which really pales in comparison to the personality-driven style of DC101. I’m wondering if they’ll eventually start building up an on-air staff (maybe bring a couple DC101 people up, or hell, grab some old HFS jocks that are still in the area), or if it’ll stay like that.
@2ironic4u: Harvey Danger is still around, yes? Their first record was one great single and a lot of meh, but their next couple records were great.
it still cracks me up that the singer from Slipknot’s real name, after being known as simply “No. 8″ all those years, turned out to be “Corey.”
“Hi, you’ve reached the Corey hot-line. $4.95 a minute. Here are some words that rhyme with Corey: Gory. Story. Allegory. Montessori.”
The Ludo disc is great. Kind of reminds me of Harvey Danger (hey, stop, they were a good band). Really suprised that Carolina Liar is moving up the Alternative chart, would’ve thought this would be a Hot AC/CHR track.
@Ned Raggett: FTW. I would’ve gone there if you hadn’t.
But all that’s changed in recent weeks: Clear Channel has flipped one of its smooth jazz stations to Channel 104.3, Baltimore’s first full-time mainstream alt-rock station in over three years.
This is very informative, thank you. In fact, I think it might explain the batshit Modern Rock chart I wrote about in my column last week - those doublings in airplay by aging Top 10 hits by the likes of Foo Fighters and Death Cab can almost only be explained by the addition of a wholly new station (or three) to the Modern format. I don’t know why I didn’t think of it sooner.
@Chris Molanphy: Interesting, it didn’t occur to me that there’d be a connection between those 2 things. So you really think the addition of one station to a relatively big format like Mod Rock would make that much of an impact, out of all the dozens (hundreds? I have no idea) of existing stations?
@Al Shipley: An interesting historical note. According to David Browne’s (very good) new Sonic Youth bio, over 100 new mod-rock stations popped up in the wake of Nirvana’s success. Might be useful to compare/contrast with the current number of stations.
@Al Shipley: Sorry, I wrote my previous comment too quickly and should’ve been clearer — I think it’s probably a combination of factors. I mean, I’m probably not wrong in my thesis last week that summer is a heavier airplay period for big rock hits in general. But there are only so many hours in the day, you know? If Offspring and Foo Fighters are seeing 140% boosts in airplay on hits that were already in the upper tiers, and everything else around them is rising, too, at least some of that has got to be the result of new stations coming online.
Usually changes to Billboard’s/BDS’s radio panel happen in, like, quarterly waves, not station-by-station/week-to-week. Maybe they added a quarter’s worth of new modern-rock stations to the panel a couple of weeks ago? I mean, we’ve been hearing that flips to rock have been increasing (bit by bit) nationwide in recent months, right?
Ludo have been touring around the Midwest for years and years. They’ve always been popular with people who are in other bands. You’d go see them in Tulsa, and half the crowd would be Tulsa groups.