Idolator
In October 2007, the Brooklyn outfit Creaky Boards was excited to see a person who resembled Coldplay's Chris Martin enjoying their CMJ festival performance. Less than a year later, that enthusiasm has turned into frustration as bandleader Andrew Hoepfner discovered that Coldplay's iTunes-ad-featured "Viva La Vida" had a melody that was kind of close to their "The Songs I Didn't Write," performed at the aforementioned concert. Did Martin go hopping from show to show at CMJ, lifting bits for his next album? Don't be daft, say the superstars; "Viva La Vida" was allegedly demoed over a year ago. This hasn't stopped Hoepfner from creating a video clip comparing the tracks and publicizing his band.
Oddly, Hoepfner notes that his song's subject, listening to the radio, would probably be a better fit for an iTunes ad than Coldplay singing about the Crusades. So far he's not seeking any financial restitution, and he's even joking that he stole the progression from Zelda on his band's blog. The similarity is vague enough that I think it's pretty canny of him to use these similarities as a way of getting the Creaky Boards some publicity, instead of going the more expensive lawsuit route. Probably won't get them closer to that Apple deal, though.
Coldplay Deny Stealing Song [Guardian]
coldplay + itunes steals viva la vida from creaky boards! [YouTube]
Comments
Sure, on a purely superficial level, it has a vague similarity to the Coldplay track. But so do roughly half the mid-tempo ballads recorded since 1972.
[blog.newsok.com]
When is the estate of Freddie Mercury going to sue this guy for moustache infringement?
"The similarity is vague enough that I think it's pretty canny of him to use these similarities as a way of getting the Creaky Boards some publicity, instead of going the more expensive lawsuit route."
And, at the end of the day, that's the whole idea, isn't it?
@Captain Wrong: Exactly. I don't see this as anything else besides more buzz for The Creaky Boards.
The Creaky Boards song is kinda...boring, slower than Coldplay's version and the melody isn't a rip-off at all. This is pointless.
Dear Creaky Boards,
Before releasing your album, bottle up that creative energy exhibited in the YouTube clip to come up with a less clunky band name!
I'm sorry, but if I happened to hear these two songs back to back without reading this article, I would think nothing of it. This Creaky Boards song is terrible, the melody is very boring and lacks hooks. "Viva La Vida," love it or hate it, is 1,000x catchier than this hack's song.
Wait, "Viva La Vida" is about the Crusades?
this happened last month, too. but the tune in question was this a french pop singer, Alize.
[chartrigger.blogspot.com]
hmm...I used to know Andrew H. and i don't think he'd stake this claim unless he meant it. He's always been a pretty stand-up guy and was a fantastic bass player.
Comment on this post
Reply by EmailLogin with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?