NEW YORK, 11:51 PM, FRI NOV 21 | 21 POSTS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS | tips@idolator.com | SUBMIT A TIP | RSS
it's the economy, stupid

"USA Today" Celebrates The Recession By Glorifying Overpriced Band Merch, Recycling Jokes From "PCU"

woodstock99.JPGToday's USA Today has a big piece on rock merch, talking about how $55 concert T-shirts are purchased by people who are "style-conscious and socially conscious" (oddly, the word "suckers" is not used), how being sold at Target hasn't hurt the alleged cool factor of Beatles and Rolling Stones shirts, and how the ever-annoying Katy Perry designed her merch in such a way that's inspired by (her apparent non-reading of) Lolita and "fruit motifs, especially strawberries and cherries." (Because eating them is, like, just like kissing a girl... plant!) It even finds some poor sucker to trot out the already-old-and-reliable "you can't download a T-shirt" notion! But perhaps the best part of the story is Edna Gudnersen's guide to "t-shirt etiquette," which seems to have been taken out of some sort of sidebar storage unit that was last replenished in 2004.

- It's geeky to wear a T-shirt you just bought at the concert you're attending. Besides, your mother would want you to wash it first.

This would seem to be Gundersen's reinterpretation of the "Don't be that guy" rule from PCU, in which Jeremy Piven's character chastises, "What's this? You're wearing the shirt of the band you're going to see? Don't be that guy." Only with laundry. And Mom. Not cool, dude.

- If you must wear a Metallica T-shirt at a Metallica concert, make sure it's from three or four tours back.

Not only does this break the aforementioned "don't be that guy" rule, it also creates the false caste system that people who actually went to see Metallica in 2003 are somehow better than "newer" fans.

- Unless you're 8, a High School Musical T-shirt will draw snickers. However, a Schoolhouse Rock! shirt is kitschy.

But if you wear it to a Blind Melon show, are you "that guy"?

I guess it depends on whether post-Shannon Hoon death Blind Melon is a different band. (Let the arguing commence!)

A Nirvana T-shirt at a Foo Fighters concert is too obvious; Melvins, maybe. A Screaming Trees shirt at a Queens of the Stone Age concert or a Green Jello shirt at a Tool show will reveal you as a fan with roots.

I wholly disagree with this idea, because it violates a corollary of the "don't be that guy" rule that I like to term as "don't be that person who is trying to have 'cred,' even though the shirt bestowing such was probably purchased at Hot Topic anyway."

- Don't wear a Woodstock or Live Aid T-shirt unless you actually attended.

- Even if you were there, don't wear a Woodstock '99 T-shirt. Why admit it?

Because comedy = tragedy + time? Hey, it's been nine years. (Really, when was this thing written?)

- Never wear a Gary Glitter T-shirt. If you don't know why, look it up.

OK, this is probably good advice. Although I did hear "Rock & Roll Pt. 2" at a sporting event recently, so who knows, his ironic rehabilitation could be just around the bend...

Concert tour T-shirts crank up the style [USA Today]

10:30 AM on Thu Jul 3 2008
By Maura Johnston
1,084 views
6 comments

Comments

  • That Metallica rule is just silly. Everyone knows the "Don't Be That Guy" rule is null and void at an arena concert. In fact, I'm pretty sure the rule is reversed at an arena show.

    Also, who wouldn't want to let people know they were at Woodstock '99? That's something to be proud of right there.

  • Don't wear an Ed Banger t-shirt to a Justice concert. i hate those ed rec vol. 2 shirts floating around their concerts everywhere

  • Those T-shirt rules are dumb. Do whatever you want I say.

    You like a band, wear the shirt. You just bought a shirt? Put it on. I'm sure the band finds it flattering to see someone proudly doing so. It's only the lame fans that give a shit.

  • Don't wear a Gary Glitter t-shirt? I suppose this guy wants me to stop wearing my Jeffrey Jones, Ferris Bueller's Day Off shirt as well.

  • It should be "The Merkins Rule", because that's the band Gutter was going to see while wearing their shirt.

    "Gutter, you do realize there was music made BEFORE 1989."

  • I guess I'm lame or something, because I am always a little bit horrified when I see someone wearing the t-shirt of the event we're at. Of course, this is more for anime conventions than concerts, but seriously, I don't need to see 50 Otakon 2008 t-shirts walking around. It's... weird.

    My personal rule is to never wear a shirt that correlates to the event I'm. Wear your movie t-shirts to concerts and your concert t-shirts to movies. You'll attract more attention and make more friends that way, if you want to.

Comment on this post

Reply by Email

Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.