From time to time, we like to round up the all-important, all-summarizing last sentences of the biggest new-music reviews. Today's entry is the much-blogged-about Florida band Black Kids' Partie Traumatic, which hits stores tomorrow.
• "'Listen to Your Body Tonight' nods to 'Take Your Time (Do It Right),' the S.O.S. Band's slinky 1980 electro-funk strut, with Youngblood urging boys and girls to jump into bed with someone. He might convince you to do so too." [RS]
• "While Democrats debated whether an African American or a woman should be our next president, Black Kids became the most buzzed-about new band since Vampire Weekend. They resembled the future but sounded like a past only plugged-in Anglophiles could've fully inhabited. But now, with confident new songs like 'Listen to Your Body Tonight,' they seize the moment by blasting past underground insularity: Their self-assured hooks position the group as winners no matter how hard their leader loses in love. Kissing goodbye to the obsolete racial and gender roles that pop, hip-hop, or indie rock still demand, Youngblood and pals throw a thrillingly subversive victory party to lift the country out of eight years of anguish." [Spin]
• "Part of the appeal of the Black Kids' approach is that they nail the technical delivery of each song on all fronts. The vocals, for the most part, sound like The Cure's Robert Smith on helium. If the music was understated, it wouldn't work as well, but the songs have a habit of coming to a crescendo nicely and giving lead singer Reggie Youngblood a platform on which to soar. If they are to be faulted for anything, it's for being a little too hook-heavy. But at least the hooks are good. Most of the songs are about sex and love and sprinkled with randy language throughout, so tender ears beware." [AP]
• "There are moments when Youngblood's vocals become too affected for their own good - he keeps doing an English accent that has a tendency to lurch around the country like a tourist on a tight schedule - and moments when the lyrical punning becomes a bit torturous: 'Like many a Mael, I've got angst in my pants,' opens 'I've Underestimated My Charm (Again),' a flurry of Sparks-related puns that even Youngblood's bandmates seem to find painful, following it with a synthesised groan. But his ear for a tight, catchy pop song and ascending chorus hardly ever lets him down. 'Listen to Your Body Tonight,' 'Hurricane Jane,' 'I'm Making Eyes at You': almost everything here sounds like a hit waiting to happen, equipped with a tune strong enough to be heard above the hype—or the hype about the hype or the people complaining about the hype about the hype—and memorable enough to make the idea that Black Kids will be forgotten by Christmas seem a highly unlikely suggestion." [Guardian]









Comments
80's nostalgia/sound/fashion is so 2005.
I've decided that we can't be out of touch not to get either Black Kids or Vampire Weekend. Why? If you remember when the records they're xeroxing came out, you can definitively recognize how neither band is nearly as good as the style they're aping.
I got VHS or Beta and I get Bloc Party. This, no.
So the Black Kids ended racism and moved our country beyond the Bush Administration? I guess that's not bad for a debut album.
Maybe I'm a little extra-sensitive today after watching Generation Kill last night and then sitting in bed all night thinking about Generation Kill. But come on, guy from Spin, just stfu please. There's no contest to see who can hype this album the hardest (or is there?). The first sentence is a non-sequitor, and the last sentence is just tripe. Thanks for making my brain (and soul) hurt that much more on this crappy crappy 10000 degree Monday afternoon.
Erm, don't confuse this with an endorsement, but in Spin boy's pop-political screed, you could probably plug in "Gym Class Heroes" for every "Black Kids" and it would read the same. Stick to the music -- the faux context doesn't work.
[blog.newsok.com]
So we're going to finally move on from hating on Vampire Weekend to these guys?
@pantycrickets: hating Vampire Weekend is still in production for at least one more season, this hatred has simply been added to the fall schedule
I gladly listen to Vampire Weekend all the time. BK, not so much.
So, did Idolator HQ burn down some time mid-morning, or what?
@loudersoft: it makes it easy that they both suck.
I'm here, I'm just on crap airport wireless that isn't letting me connect to anything Idolator-related. I'm actually typing this comment via my phone, and if typing wasn't so cumbersome I'd probably do the whole damn site this way today. And people wonder why I'm suspicious ofvtechnology sometimes ...
@dog door: But only one of them sucks in cardigans.
Man, what is with all the hate? No, they're not the best band of all time, but they're the best band lately. What, we should listen to nothing but the Arcade Fire? It's OK to like happy music.
@Maura Johnston: Oh, yeah, you're in Germany or something, right? I feel like I shouldn't know that, and yet I do.
My favorite part of the album was when they got Mugabe and Tsvangirai to agree to a power-sharing arrangement.
@DavidWatts: Chicago. Never ever buy wireless from boingo.com, as it's the absolute pits.
@Felonious Monk: I like happy music, but I tend to prefer said happy music to mix in things like competency and not sounding like later-period Hot Hot Heat.
@DavidWatts: Isn't Maura part of the Obama World Tour press entourage? I think she's working on a 10,000-word piece for Rolling Stone right now called "Obama: Kraftwerk or Justice? Amy Winehouse or Carla Bruni? America Demands Answers".
You guys make my life sound so much more glamorous than it really is!
nothing wrong with happy music. you're assuming we don't like it because it's happy. we don't like it because it sucks. i love the hold steady, and they're as happy and as derivative as BK. I find BK seriously uninspired, and lacking a core of joy, two things I find in the Hold Steady.
@Aquemini: So, let me get this straight. You hate everything in the world except for Jesus Jones and Vampire Weekend?!?
@GhostOfDuane: Seriously, that review at Spin is OUT of control.
@Maura Johnston: Boingo is awful!! -- surely someone reading this can hook you up with a Verizon or a Sprint WiCard.
@loudersoft: I've heard Oingo is the one you want.
GROOOOOAAAAAAN.
Apologies all around.
@Aquemini: Who says the hype around Black Kids isn't just a byproduct of bring nostalgiac for 2005's version of the 80s?
@Maura Johnston: Well yeah, flying around the globe, splurging on wireless internet in the airport... You're the height of glamour.
@spazandmojo: Thank you for noticing, I feel somewhat less crazy now.
Is this now an open thread? If so, I'd like to talk about Rick Ross's former career as a corrections officer for the Florida Department of Corrections.
[www.thesmokinggun.com]
If not, you know, carry on talking about Black Kids.
The band.
Kissing goodbye to the obsolete racial and gender roles
Feigning outdated amazement at women and nonwhites in bands = more signs of an early '90s revival?
@loudersoft: Indeed.
Please see this band live and you will think shey suck as much as I do.
@GhostOfDuane and spazandmojo: Really? I thought that was right on. I'm a Black woman and I play guitar, and it's all to heal. Heal YOU!!!
Hey, I just looked at the Pitchfork review, and I'm pretty sure it was 0.0, and then I refreshed the page and it went up to 3.3 and the reviewer's name changed... I am sitting rather dozily in front of my computer at work and it is only Tuesday, but...have I imagined the 0.0 review?
@jetblackturd: No, I just noticed the same thing. When the review first went up around 5, it had a different writer, a 0 score, and a front-page tag that said "We all make mistakes." Still had the dog pic though. Hm...
@jetblackturd: I saw it too. I must say I'm disappointed in Pitchfork... are they too lazy to write a proper review? I know they're just coming off their festival, but still...
Pretty sure the "writer" on the original review was Ray Suzuki, who was also credited with that one Jet review. Anybody know whose pseudonym that is?
Bingo. Punch "Ray Suzuki Pitchfork" into google and the BKs review is the third thing down, though the link takes you to the Plagenhoef review.
@janine: Yes.
Pugs are SO fall 06 through Summer 07.
It was simply a computer error left over from our server change a few weeks back. An eariler version of this same review-- created before we were sure we were going to run that, and with a placeholder rating, subhead, and author name (an old inside joke resurrected for the Jet review, which was conceived by a few people over lunch rather than one author)*-- was ported over and accidentally 'reverted to' in our system when I woke and it was changed asap. Sorry...it's a boring technical difficulty.
* It also takes three or four of us to change a lightbulb.
@janine: are you debbie from curve? ;)
I was healed a long time ago, promise. :)
@scottpl: Darn, I was hoping DiCrescenzo had gone absurdist and was working under an alias. Ah, the good old days...
@ddb4: DiCrescenzo's at Time Out Chicago now. FYI.
Are you guys serious???....SERIOUSLY???...have u guys even listened to Black Kids or have you just read their hyped up articles...these Kids are SICK...the songs are immediate and FUN, and I don't think that the band itself ever lays claim that they are trying to replicate any past eras or bands.... they're doing what all other music lovers/performers do- try to make music that they enjoy and that hopefully others will to, maybe even bring things to a more progressive level, which I feel that they did...so, good for them....Go Black Kids!!!
@21pathsoftheson: Hi Columbia street-teamer!
hello;-)
(actually, I'm not a street-teamer... just your average music appreciator)
@21pathsoftheson: You know I was going to post something defending the band and insisting the hype brought upon the bad Pitchfork review because their EP got an 8.4 on the same site, but i'm not now. In fact because of your post I like them less. Thanks!
Comment on this post
Reply by EmailLogin with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?