Comments on: Can You Pick The New Oasis Song Out Of This Somewhat Lengthy Montage? http://idolator.com/399550/can-you-pick-the-new-oasis-song-out-of-this-somewhat-lengthy-montage Music News, Reviews, and Gossip on Idolator.com Sat, 11 Feb 2012 12:55:40 -0800 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: moomintroll http://idolator.com/399550/can-you-pick-the-new-oasis-song-out-of-this-somewhat-lengthy-montage/comment-page-1#comment-659222 moomintroll Fri, 01 Aug 2008 02:47:49 +0000 852faeaa8b9ce07b3f240d6997bc6025#comment-659222 <p>It all sounds like the same song except for Wonderwall, which is their only claim to greatness. I was right on board until about the 1:30 mark...which coincided with the time period I left Oasis behind for greener pastures. Not to get all NME circa 1995 about it (o.k it's the NME, so I should say circa 2008 since they'll never let the glory days of britpop go, even if the NME's current age demographic was 2 at the time) BUT: If you did the same montage with Blur songs over the years it would be obvious that they took risks and changed their sound...grew out of britpop even. Now, there's something to be said about plodding along with the same sound, and kudos to Oasis for staying together this long (O.K so the lineup has changed about a million times...but well done anyway!)<br> I applaud their consistency, even if it is steeped in mediocrity. People say that Blur won the battle, but Oasis won the war of britpop. Maybe winning that war is what sealed their fate as a one trick pony, the creative heights that Damon Albarn has reached since then only highlight Oasis' lack of progression. Maybe "losing" the britpop war all those years ago was the best thing that could have happened to Albarn, since it's freed him up to become a creative genius...as opposed to well, doing the same album over and over.<br> O.K...I'll get out of my time warp, I grew up in England, and the whole britpop war thing was happening when I was 14, so it's what's shaped my whole musical identity. You HAD to choose!</p> It all sounds like the same song except for Wonderwall, which is their only claim to greatness. I was right on board until about the 1:30 mark…which coincided with the time period I left Oasis behind for greener pastures. Not to get all NME circa 1995 about it (o.k it’s the NME, so I should say circa 2008 since they’ll never let the glory days of britpop go, even if the NME’s current age demographic was 2 at the time) BUT: If you did the same montage with Blur songs over the years it would be obvious that they took risks and changed their sound…grew out of britpop even. Now, there’s something to be said about plodding along with the same sound, and kudos to Oasis for staying together this long (O.K so the lineup has changed about a million times…but well done anyway!)
I applaud their consistency, even if it is steeped in mediocrity. People say that Blur won the battle, but Oasis won the war of britpop. Maybe winning that war is what sealed their fate as a one trick pony, the creative heights that Damon Albarn has reached since then only highlight Oasis’ lack of progression. Maybe “losing” the britpop war all those years ago was the best thing that could have happened to Albarn, since it’s freed him up to become a creative genius…as opposed to well, doing the same album over and over.
O.K…I’ll get out of my time warp, I grew up in England, and the whole britpop war thing was happening when I was 14, so it’s what’s shaped my whole musical identity. You HAD to choose!

]]> By: Thierry http://idolator.com/399550/can-you-pick-the-new-oasis-song-out-of-this-somewhat-lengthy-montage/comment-page-1#comment-659232 Thierry Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:51:41 +0000 852faeaa8b9ce07b3f240d6997bc6025#comment-659232 <p>Is it just me or does Liam's voice sound processed within an inch of its life? He hasn't sounded very good live in recent years, and I'm starting to think his voice is gone...</p> Is it just me or does Liam’s voice sound processed within an inch of its life? He hasn’t sounded very good live in recent years, and I’m starting to think his voice is gone…

]]> By: dtopping http://idolator.com/399550/can-you-pick-the-new-oasis-song-out-of-this-somewhat-lengthy-montage/comment-page-1#comment-659242 dtopping Wed, 30 Jul 2008 09:39:05 +0000 852faeaa8b9ce07b3f240d6997bc6025#comment-659242 <p>It doesn't suck! This is very exciting.</p> It doesn’t suck! This is very exciting.

]]> By: Maura Johnston http://idolator.com/399550/can-you-pick-the-new-oasis-song-out-of-this-somewhat-lengthy-montage/comment-page-1#comment-659252 Maura Johnston Wed, 30 Jul 2008 09:18:02 +0000 852faeaa8b9ce07b3f240d6997bc6025#comment-659252 <p>@<a href="#c6966663">ParrishBrown</a>: are you from a district attorney's office in florida, perhaps?</p> @ParrishBrown: are you from a district attorney’s office in florida, perhaps?

]]> By: ParrishBrown http://idolator.com/399550/can-you-pick-the-new-oasis-song-out-of-this-somewhat-lengthy-montage/comment-page-1#comment-659262 ParrishBrown Wed, 30 Jul 2008 09:09:25 +0000 852faeaa8b9ce07b3f240d6997bc6025#comment-659262 <p>you know what other classic tune rhymes that?</p> <p>You are my fire<br> The one desire<br> Believe when I say<br> I want it that way</p> <p>that's right, BSB. guess i'm just in a lou perlman mood.</p> you know what other classic tune rhymes that?

You are my fire
The one desire
Believe when I say
I want it that way

that’s right, BSB. guess i’m just in a lou perlman mood.

]]>