Comments on: Here’s Hoping Kara DioGuardi Didn’t Sign A Long-Term Deal With “Idol” http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol Music News, Reviews, and Gossip on Idolator.com Sun, 27 May 2012 01:59:39 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892442 Anonymous Wed, 01 Apr 2009 07:41:39 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892442 <p>I think the main reason she was added so was that we would stop complaining about Randy.</p> I think the main reason she was added so was that we would stop complaining about Randy.

]]> By: Nicolars http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892452 Nicolars Wed, 01 Apr 2009 06:58:07 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892452 <p>@<a href="#c11781695">Varina</a>: I swear, she uses "package artist" more than Randy Jackson uses the word "dawg".</p> @Varina: I swear, she uses “package artist” more than Randy Jackson uses the word “dawg”.

]]> By: Varina http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892462 Varina Wed, 01 Apr 2009 06:43:18 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892462 <p>She's just not doing it for me, and I had very high hopes for her, since she's so much more current than the other judges, and she knows that it's more than spot-on vocals and a ton of belting that makes a hit. However, she's turned out to be sort of useless, and anything constructive is buried beneath more name dropping of Adele and "package artist."</p> She’s just not doing it for me, and I had very high hopes for her, since she’s so much more current than the other judges, and she knows that it’s more than spot-on vocals and a ton of belting that makes a hit. However, she’s turned out to be sort of useless, and anything constructive is buried beneath more name dropping of Adele and “package artist.”

]]> By: Nicolars http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892472 Nicolars Wed, 01 Apr 2009 06:20:51 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892472 <p>If you believe the Enquirer (hey, they were right about John Edwards), Simon has hated her for weeks now and will be cutting her loose at the end of the season.</p> If you believe the Enquirer (hey, they were right about John Edwards), Simon has hated her for weeks now and will be cutting her loose at the end of the season.

]]> By: Chris Molanphy http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892482 Chris Molanphy Wed, 01 Apr 2009 06:12:55 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892482 <p>@<a href="#c11779443">Al Shipley</a>: IAWTC.</p> @Al Shipley: IAWTC.

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892492 Anonymous Wed, 01 Apr 2009 05:48:03 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892492 <p>i will eat my hat (or at least danny gokey's glasses) the day that kara takes a stance contrary to the other three judges. a while back (top 36?) she went first and gave a typically vague but distinctly negative opinion of the performance while the others proceeded to heap praise on the contestant.</p> <p>you could see her face fall.</p> <p>since that time, when she goes first, she recycles her stand-by "broken record" critiques, remains vague, and only expresses a strong opinion if she knows the others are going to like it (paula standing and dancing, gokey or lambert, huge crowd response, etc.)</p> i will eat my hat (or at least danny gokey’s glasses) the day that kara takes a stance contrary to the other three judges. a while back (top 36?) she went first and gave a typically vague but distinctly negative opinion of the performance while the others proceeded to heap praise on the contestant.

you could see her face fall.

since that time, when she goes first, she recycles her stand-by “broken record” critiques, remains vague, and only expresses a strong opinion if she knows the others are going to like it (paula standing and dancing, gokey or lambert, huge crowd response, etc.)

]]> By: Anonymous http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892502 Anonymous Wed, 01 Apr 2009 05:44:39 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892502 <P>this whole focus on marketability is making Idol hard to watch, IMO. which isn't to say that kara's contributions aren't valuable ones, but...i wouldn't miss her.</P> this whole focus on marketability is making Idol hard to watch, IMO. which isn’t to say that kara’s contributions aren’t valuable ones, but…i wouldn’t miss her.

]]> By: Al Shipley http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892512 Al Shipley Wed, 01 Apr 2009 05:29:05 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892512 <P>DioGuardi is kind of obnoxious and doesn't bring as much substance to the judges' comments as I'd hoped she would, but I'm still grateful to have a new dynamic. The original trio had gotten pretty insufferable by last season.</P> DioGuardi is kind of obnoxious and doesn’t bring as much substance to the judges’ comments as I’d hoped she would, but I’m still grateful to have a new dynamic. The original trio had gotten pretty insufferable by last season.

]]> By: Thierry http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892522 Thierry Wed, 01 Apr 2009 05:23:56 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892522 <p>I think the only value DioGuardi adds to the show is how she blocks Randy from getting involved in the Simon-Paula tryst (since they just won't look to their right anymore).</p> I think the only value DioGuardi adds to the show is how she blocks Randy from getting involved in the Simon-Paula tryst (since they just won’t look to their right anymore).

]]> By: Maura Johnston http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892532 Maura Johnston Wed, 01 Apr 2009 04:58:33 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892532 <p>@<a href="#c11778434">musicquizking</a>: there are many reasons that he was not made for the hd age, and yes, that is another one of them.</p> @musicquizking: there are many reasons that he was not made for the hd age, and yes, that is another one of them.

]]> By: musicquizking http://idolator.com/5194045/heres-hoping-kara-dioguardi-didnt-sign-a-long-term-deal-with-idol/comment-page-1#comment-892542 musicquizking Wed, 01 Apr 2009 04:53:50 +0000 http://d56ec9b15b51cebf5825f8bf975a9b43#comment-892542 <p>Is it just me or does anyone else notice Adam Lambert's horrible skin underneath the cake of makeup?</p> Is it just me or does anyone else notice Adam Lambert’s horrible skin underneath the cake of makeup?

]]>