The Best Defense Is A Good Offense Dept.

“In a response filed in Los Angeles on Monday, attorneys for Coldplay’s band members also argued that any similarities between ‘Viva La Vida’ and Satriani’s ‘If I Could Fly’ weren’t enough to warrant damages. Satriani’s song ‘lacks originality,’ Coldplay’s response claims, and shouldn’t receive copyright protection.” Uh, guys? You may want to talk to your lawyers about that old proverb regarding pots and kettles… [AP / Previously]

 
Joe Satriani is suing Coldplay, alleging Viva La Vida uses his melody ...
Coldplay vs Joe Satriani - Actualité musicale sur Musity
Did Coldplay rip off Joe Satriani? | PopWatch | EW.com
STEVE SMITH: Classic rock, pop and country
Other performers include Paul McCartney, The Foo Fighters, Coldplay with Rihanna ... that also includes guitar deity Joe Satriani and Red Hot Chili Peppers drummer Chad Smith, smokes their old band. "If you take Satriani versus Eddie, you ...



 
  1. Chris Molanphy  |   Posted on Apr 7th, 2009

    Tru dat, but I have to imagine the “lacks originality” line is legalese they have to put out there as the basis for their case. I.e., We never heard this song before we wrote “Viva,” but even if we did, that specific aggregation of notes isn’t singular enough to require intellectual-property protection. In short, this reads more like the work of an attorney than the demure-to-a-fault Chris Martin.

  2. Anonymous  |   Posted on Apr 8th, 2009

    So Coldplay’s lawyer is basically saying, “Satriani’s song isn’t original…and my client ALSO doesn’t release songs that are original.”

Leave a Reply

Sign In Login