Get Ready To Hear A Lot Of Pontificating About The Best Records Of The Decade

ghostsIt’s almost the end of June in a year that ends in a nine! What that means: The runup to crafting “Best Records Of The Decade” lists by those people who are still holding on to the music-writer dream despite all evidence to the contrary is going to begin very soon, and get pretty heated as the days get shorter and the temperatures begin dropping. (Although you know what’s going to be even worse? Doing it all over again next year for those people who sniff that “since there was no year zero, a decade runs from 01-10, piker.”)


Some people have already started in on the process; if you want to go back and remember the big songs of the past 10 years, Intensities In Ten Suburbs, which is currently at No. 93 on its 100-best-songs-of-the-decade countdown, is a good place to start. (Remember the whole “Wait (The Whisper Song)” kerfuffle?) Honestly, I have no idea what I’d put on any list beyond Siobhan Donaghy’s Ghosts, “A Stroke Of Genie-Us,” and any/all Ida Maria-related things (and yes I’d put her on the list even if she emerged in ‘01 not ‘08) but perhaps you have your iTunes-tracking spreadsheets and PowerPoint presentations in the works already? Feel free to share any outstanding items that simply must be on everyone’s list in the comments section here. Perhaps we can all come to some sort of consensus by the end of the week, so we can move on and try to start predicting what records will be the best of 2010-11!


Intensities In Ten Suburbs [HT Sound Of The City]

 

  • LeighBlack
    Hmmmm. Matt Nathanson's Some Mad Hope, for sure. And Butch Walker's Letters. Those are the two that immediately spring to mind.
  • TheRunningboard7
    I think Between the Buried and Me's Colors is the best metal album of the decade, and while I'm not suggesting the representatives of every make believe sub-genre be present, I think they'd be my primary harder-music representative.

    ... and I think Bear Vs. Shark's Terrorhawk is the most under-appreciated album of the decade.
  • Lucas Jensen
    I love Okay's High Road/Low Road duo and Super Furry Animals' Rings Around The World. Those are the ones that just popped into my head. I haven't really thought about this at all, actually, and I might not because it kinda stresses me out.
  • yuppiescum
    I'm a little ubran-centric and might get labeled a populist, but in a decade definitely dominated by hip hop pop, I'd submit: Marshall Mathers LP (almost the hands down #1), Good Girl Gone Bad, Tha Carter III, and Word of Mouf.

    Rock wise, the first Franz Ferdinand and End of Heartache by KSE deserve to be in the discussion.
  • slowburn
    @Lucas Jensen: Doesn't it, though? I got hives just reading the title of this post!
  • This post (the content, not the style) has sort of ruined my day.
  • Since I Left You by The Avalanches sort of ruined it for everyone else this decade by coming out in 2000 and being the best of the best for the next 9 years.
  • All of The Strokes albums.
  • thesemodernsocks
    @brasstax: best of the decade aside, that MUST be on a list to be credible

    Put that along with Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, Kill the Moonlight, White Blood Cells and Kid A

    All bona fide.
  • @thesemodernsocks: Thanks for agreeing, but unfortunately I can't return the favor. My White Stripes pick would be Elephant and I probably wouldn't put any Wilco, Spoon or Radiohead on it. Not to be contrarian, but my personal favorites by each of them came out in the 90s and I haven't really embraced them as much this decade (although the latest Wilco album is really pretty good).
  • Also (and I think @Maura will have my back on this), the Life Without Buildings album needs to be way up there...I'd probably have it at #2 on my own list.
  • LostTurntable
    I'm working on my list right now for a site I write for and it's a real pain. I feel the need to support genres that I like that other guys on the site kind of ignore (indie hip-hop, electronic music) and sifting through 10 years of records is a bitch, even if it is just an iTunes playlist.
  • drinkypuss
    Drive-By Truckers, the Dirty South. Best Hard Rock album of the decade, maybe, possibly, definitely.

    and the Micachu, for real.
  • slowburn
    @brasstax: I don't see how in the world anyone does a "best of" decade list without Kid A. Its influence was huge.
  • @slowburn: I like some of the songs on Kid A (and the other Radiohead albums from this decade too), but as a whole it's too wanky/detached for me to really go back to it that often.
  • sicksteanein
    @brasstax: Ya I totally miss that inclusive warmth of the 90s radiohead albums. :)
  • Weakling's Dead as Dreams (probably the best goddamn black metal album ever), Kate Bush's Aerial, Fugazi's The Argument (your list is worthless without this), Scott Walker's The Drift, Jay-Z's The Blueprint, Cursive's Domestica, etc. etc. etc.

    Good fuckin' decade, here.
  • Thierry
    Even if it was 38 years late, Brian Wilson's SMiLe has to be on it, and I'm a little surprised Stankonia hasn't come up yet.

    I'd be okay if Franz Ferdinand's debut made it onto some lists and while it might not be a popular pick (though I bet it will be in the UK), so should the Libertines' first album.
  • enaek
    Sophie Ellis-Bextor's entire musical career, but Trip the Light Fantastic especially. Minority of one, I'm sure. I think Liz Phair was pretty awesome, and holds up even today as a great pop-rock record, but again, minority of one.

    Oh! I have one that someone else might agree with me on! But does Bachelor No. 2 count as being in this decade?
  • slowburn
    @brasstax: *Nanananana I can't hear you!*

    Other contenders: Lauryn Hill's Miseducation, D'Angelo's Voodoo, the Avalanches of course, fucking Kid A, Spoon's GaGaGaGaGa, Interpol's Turn on the Bright Lights (a shame about everything they've done since then), the Strokes' first album.

    I'm on the fence about Dr. Dre's The Chronic. Huge impact, but it hasn't aged so well.
  • slowburn
    Oh, and Daft Punk's Discovery. I'm surprised that one hasn't come up yet either.
  • Thierry
    @slowburn: Wait - so the 90s and the 00s are all one decade?
  • "1 Thing" might be my hands-down favorite single, but there were a ton of good albums this decade. Just to cherry pick a couple: Beanie Sigel - The B Coming, Circulatory System - s/t, Daft Punk - Discovery, M Ward - Transfiguration of Vincent, Queens of the Stone Age - Rated R, Kid A, Wilco - YHF
  • slowburn
    @Thierry: How so? Discovery came out in 2001, The Chronic came out in 2001, Miseducation....oh shit, Miseducation. Oops.
  • Thierry
    @slowburn: Chronic came out in 1992 - 2001, appropriately enough, came out in 2001. :)

    Also, I'm on the fence about which Basement Jaxx album I'd nominate - Rooty is probably the one that'll make it, but they were all pretty great.
  • @slowburn: Um, not be a snob, but Miseducation came out in 1998.
  • Re: Basement Jaxx. Kish Kash for me, but I'm really optimistic about the one upcoming.

    I figured there were probably still people out there who listened to the first Strokes album, but the NYC of this decade has to be the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, right?
  • not to be all difficult and shit, but isn't the whole point of best of lists to be subjective, and interesting? how can you make claims like, if it doesn't include kid a, or the avalanches record, it's not credible? i'd rather read a hundred lists that include shit i've never even heard of than one that was all is this it?, fuckin' yankee hotel foxtrot (the beginning of the end for the best band of the 90s), seven nation army, blah blah blah blah blah. this is the kind of herd mentality that made fleet fuckin' foxes the BEST RECORD OF 2008!!11!121!!!
  • cheesebubble
    This is too hard! Having heart palpitations just trying to muster up all the albums from the past decade. Might be back with some goodies later. Or not.
  • slowburn
    @brooklynradio: I'm sure you're less of a snob than Thierry, but I did figure that out.

    @iantenna: I know, I know. We'll all have to take a lot of deep breaths. It's only June 2009!
  • Name The Bats
    Chronic 2001 was November '99, I think, by which time most end-of-decade lists had probably been complied.

    I wish we had more best-of lists starting mid-decade (say instead of 90-99, go 95-04). I don't know if music trends would actually rise and fall on a different schedule or if we'd just have a new way of perceiving things. All I know is I want to live in a world where "Shook Ones, Pt. II" is duking it out with "Galang."
  • Thierry
    @slowburn: Not a snob at all (okay, maybe a bit - I do get annoyed at - part of it is that I've had to DJ a 90s night for the last couple of years, and it's made me extra-conscious of what's been released in the 90s and what's from the 00s.

    @iantenna: Subjective? Okay, I'll include Ash's Free All Angels then.
  • Chris Molanphy
    For me this was a decade of singles, not albums, and I for one would be happy to help contribute to a poptimists' best-of-the-aughts list. I've been formulating a Top 10 in my head for about a year now.
  • droopy
    well to start with:
    Baxter Dury - Len's parrot memorial lift
    The Walkmen - Bows and Arrows
    The Avalanches - Since I left you
    The Unicorns - Who will cut our hair...
    The Streets - Original PIrate Material
    Daniel Johnston - Fear Yourself
    Grandaddy - The Sophtware slump
    Hood - Outside Closer
    Hymie's Basement - Hymie's basement
    Jeff Lewis - The last time I did acid
    Jens Lekman - When I said I wanted to be your dog
    Liars - THey threw us...
    Maximilian Hecker - Infinite Love songs
    Micah P Hinson - Micah P Hinson and the gospel of progress
    Pelle Carlberg - In a Nutshell
    Peter and the wolf - Leftovers
    Shearwater - Winged Life
    Sr Chinaro - El ventriculo de si mismo
    Sufjan stevens - Michigan
    Test Icicles - For screening purposes only
    The Coral - The Coral
    Flaming Lips - Yoshimi
    The LIbertines - Up The Bracket
    The Notwist - Neon Golden
    going to sleep now
  • thesemodernsocks
    @iantenna: and subjectively, if those aren't on the list as "Best," you lose credibility. Thats how.

    And, thats was the question, right? What's going to be on everyone's list, not "what left field record you and three other people loved will make your list."

    If that was the case, I would throw up The Deadly Snakes- Ode To Joy- pure bliss!
  • thesemodernsocks
    Oops- lose credibity with me, as a subjective, self-interested listener, i mean
  • thesemodernsocks
    grand don't come for free? anybody?
  • TheRunningboard7
    @LostTurntable: Blu &Exile's album deserves to be up there I think, for sure. Aside from that, I haven't found much in the way of indie-esque hip hop that's grabbed me (but I'd certainly love to hear some).
  • thesemodernsocks
    @TheRunningboard7: What about Madvillainy?
  • TheRunningboard7
    @thesemodernsocks: MF DOOM's projects in general have high high high points, but I haven't found one I can dig from start to finish, so this is something I'm willing to give a shot.
  • SonofaVondruke
    Yeah, I've seen this end of the decade list overkill coming for a while now. It's bound to be bad. There's already way too much list assemblage at the end of any year, so this should just be too bonkers.

    But, if I MUST weigh in, keeping in mind trying to not just double up on what's gotten love above (Wilco, Radiohead, Avalanches, Sufjan)...

    For me, A.C. Newman's The Slow Wonder has been pretty much the slept-on great album of the decade. And I'm surprised no one else has mentioned Modest Mouse's The Moon and Antarctica yet. Do we all just hate that band now because it got too popular? Hell, I'd even throw in that Ugly Cassanova album for decade's best consideration.
  • @SonofaVondruke: re: Modest Mouse. On the contrary, I'd say they're a better band on the last two albums than they ever were before (and I used to really *hate* them before).
  • Thierry
    @SonofaVondruke: If The Slow Wonder's been slept on, what about the first two New Pornographers albums? They may not be as willfully artful as Neko Case's own releases, but as guitar pop, they are just about perfect.

    Another one I forgot is Robyn's self-titled album, which might also count as album of the decade just because it seems its worlwide release dates were spread over the entire decade (I exaggerate, but not by much).
  • @Thierry: How would you settle on a definitive version of the Robyn album, though? Along with its staggered worldwide releases, it also has about 8 different tracklisitings.
  • D.R.Mosby
    I'm surprised that we're 40+ posts into this discussion without any mention of Funeral by Arcade Fire.
  • I'm not.
  • @NunyaB: Yes! To Sophie and to Liz!

    Over on my blog I've been reviewing my (original) top 10 singles lists from each year this decade, and planned to do two songs a week so I'd hit 2009 by (approximately) late November, but it's like halfways through the year and I'm still on 2001, so, you know, who knows if I'll even finish.

    No idea what I'd put on a best albums list, for some reason, although I can think of plenty of singles that I might call the best (Hellooooooo, Sunshine Anderson.)
  • TheRunningboard7
    @brasstax: I remember in 2001, freshman year, this dude I met says "you ever heard of modest mouse?" and I say, "no, why" and he says hold on. Through methods which I'm sure are illegal he produces a burnt cd of everything they'd released and says "tell me if you can stand even a solid minute of this"

    I could not. At all.

    Then came Johnny Marr!!!!!!!!
  • I just want to predict:

    Daft Punk tops Pitchfork
    American Idiot tops Rolling Stone
    Kid A tops Spin and Magnet
  • joshooaah
    You can already sort of guess what Pitchfork will say, they did a list for 2000-04.
    http://pitchfork.com/features/staff-lists/5956-...
  • @TheRunningboard7: It's not even that, really, because Johnny Marr's real contribution to the last album wasn't as big as advertised. Isaac's just writing better songs now I guess.
  • TheRunningboard7
    @brasstax: I reference him for timing purposes. I've been able to enjoy or tolerate every song they've put out since he joined them.
  • Rob Tannenbaum
    Fifty posts proving/exemplifying Christopher R. Weingarten's recent diagnosis, and one post from Christopher R. Weingarten.
  • Thierry
    Also, Vampire Weekend, Cold War Kids and Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, anyone?
  • I'd probably throw Vampire Weekend in there. I still listen to that album a bunch.
  • Thierry
    @brasstax: I knew I should've added an emoticon...I was actually wondering which one of the three was going to be Pitchfork's or others' "Sorry!" pick, like Spin - still - apologizing for ranking TFC over Nirvana in 1991.
  • @Thierry: Pitchfork's already sort of overcompensated for initially rating CYHSY so highly in the beginning by trashing or reluctantly covering all the things they've done since (not that they should've ever been rated all that highly to begin with).
  • Lucas Jensen
    @Thierry: I'm the lone TFC defender here. I like that album at least as much as Nevermind.
  • Thierry
    @Lucas Jensen: You're not alone.
  • thesemodernsocks
    I'll add this- Love and Theft remains a career highlight for Dylan, but is kind of out of step with this whole millenium, I wonder how much love it will get.

    From me, it still gets lots. It makes its way into my rotation easily once every other month, and has since 9/11.
  • baconfat
    chinese muthafuckin democracy: we waited long enough, right? it should be considered the best album EVAR.
  • cruncherman
    Have you seen those laughably bad "best of" lists at Amazon? Perfect case in point --more music illiterates doing the bidding of the labels.
blog comments powered by Disqus