Katie Stevens and Andrew Garcia are doing the loser rounds (we mean that in the nicest way possible!) on TV following their ousting from American Idol last week. Last night they hit up The Late Show With David Letterman, where Dave proceeded to ask Katie a series of random questions like, “What do you get—do you get a prize? Do you get some coupons?” Katie’s flat reply: “We get this.” Catch Season 9′s eighth- and ninth-placing contestants performing about a minute of Chris Brown and Keri Hilson’s “Superhuman” on Letterman after the jump.
“You know, I think at this point in the competition, it comes down to ‘Do you want to be there, or do you not want to be there?’ ” Lambert said. “You’ve got to step it up, get some caffeine going. They were a little sleepy.”
Ah, caffeine. So that’s what would have made them better.