Jesse Tyler Ferguson, who plays Mitchell on ABC’s Modern Family, hit up New York venue Joe’s Pub last week to perform at music countdown show Our Hit Parade. And grab onto your jagged hats, monsters, because Jesse belted out a highly camp version of Lady Gaga’s latest single, “Alejandro.” Kenny Melman, co-creator of Our Hit Parade (and one half of cabaret duo Kiki and Herb), tickled the ivories as Ferguson had a bit of a drama on stage while singing. Head below to watch the theatrical rendition of the song (complete with some improv on Gaga’s lyrics).

Gaga, meanwhile, was spotted out and about in Los Angeles late last week while preparing to shoot the “Alejandro” video.

So do you think she would approve of Jesse and Kenny’s cover of her latest Top 20 hit? Or would she find it to be a complete drag?