Earlier today, Disney starlet Selena Gomez uploaded a 17-second look at her “A Year Without Rain” music video to her Twitter and —surprise!—the vid has the Teen Choice Award-winner prancing around in a windy desert. The Sahara-like setting for the “Round And Round” songstress’ clip felt so familiar (or dare we say, overdone), that in addition to this sneak peek, we’re including eight of the best music videos that take place in a similar arid landscape. Jump below to judge for yourself how Selena’s vid measured up to these other desert greats.

First, here’s Selena’s super short sneak peek:

Now, onto the Eight Best Desert Music Videos:

“Say You’ll Be There” – Spice Girls

“Imma Be” – Black Eyed Peas

“That Don’t Impress Me Much” – Shania Twain

“Your Love Is My Drug” – Ke$ha

“crushcrushcrush” – Paramore

“I Hate This Part” – The Pussy Cat Dolls

“Give It Away Now” – Red Hot Chili Peppers

“Desert Rose” – Sting

How do you think “A Year Without Rain” held up compared to the other desert classics? Comment below.