Whatcha Say: The Good, Bad & McCreery In This Week’s Reader’s Comments

May 27th, 2011 // 10 Comments

In case you were still hiding out in a cave this week, waiting for The Rapture to subside, there are two things you should know: 1.) the world is still here; and 2.) a little show called American Idol wrapped up its tenth season with 17-year-old North Carolina country crooner Scotty McCreery being declared the winner over Lauren Alaina. Naturally our readers had plenty to say about the results. Catch an earful below!

Scotty McCreery Lauren Alaina American Idol finale:: Why was disappointed (to say the least) with the results on And The Winner Of American Idol Season 10 Is…: “Another loser who is going to put out a crappy lackluster CD. Lee who? David who? Kris who? More room in this bitch for KELLY! Kelly! Kelly!”

:: On the flip side, Pen was thrilled: “Definitely deserved it! Past 4 years my fave of the top 2 WON!!!! David Cook best of the best!!!! Would have loved Casey in the final 2 though, but since he wasn’t, SO glad Scotty WON!!! Talented AND a great person! Very cool!”

:: Likewise, TTT felt good about a Scotty win: “Even if he didnt win american idol he would have had an awesome career as a country singer…”

:: Hayleys #1 was rooting more for…well, you can guess who: “Scotty sucks. hes the worst idol winner. at least the last few gave variety and was more relatable to ALL ameriacans rather country fans. Haley should have won but i would have settled for Lauren because at least she can sing and could most likely sing in other genres.”

Scotty McCreery American Idol:: Greg had an answer for Should Scotty McCreery Have Won American Idol?: “Haley should have won. It angers me when people call her a bitch. You don’t know her. And all she did was stick up for herself. If a guy did that, no one would think twice about it, but because she a girl, she’s a ‘bitch.’ Ridiculous. She was the most diverse, the most talented, and the most enjoyable, in my opinion. Having said that, I have nothing against the other contestants, and congratulations to Scotty. I wish him the best.”

:: Mike let his Beyonce flag fly proudly on American Idol Finale: We Rank The Performances: “I agree with your #1 pick. Bey stole the show and snatched every wig in the game but J Lo was pretty embarrassing. LOL at TLC. WTF, right?”

:: Xadax wasn’t feeling the new song from the Queen Bey, however: “Worst season EVER! 1+1 should’ve been near the bottom, no matter if she was right vocally but if the song is stupid (like a Gaga song = hair) then it comes off absurd.”

Adam Lambert American Idol holding hands boyfriend finale Sauli Kosikinen:: Simon was hatin’ on the Glam One on Adam Lambert, David Archuleta & More Attend Idol Season Finale: “That Lambert guy and his boyfriend. Did he have to hold his hand? He is the ultimate fame who**, just wants a gossipy fame. My grandma thinks his make-up makes him so ugly and unnatural. Why does this guy need make-up? Worst idol.”

:: Darlene, in turn, gave Simon the smackdown: “why shouldn’t he hold hands with his boyfriend? and if you dislike him so much why come and look at pictures of him, and who cares what your grandma thinks, i am a grandma and i think he is beautiful inside and out, make up or no make up.”

:: Justin M came to Mother Monster’s rescue on Lady Gaga Kicks Off Good Morning America Summer Concert Series: “What’s up with everyone hatin’ on hair? It’s a fun song . . . i’m not sure Gaga’s music is supposed to be taken 100% seriously! I mean she sings about disco sticks, bluffin with muffins, Highway Unicorns, government hookers and guys named Alejandro for heavens sake!”


  1. Slinky

    Adam Lambert is AMAZING! Sara the only disgrace in America are people that think and say offensive things like you. Thank God you and your type are in the minority.

  2. Xadax

    Lambert all the way!

  3. sara

    Trust me. I am not in the minority. Google everything I said. All out there. At 30, he doesn’t know what’s right or wrong. Probably he will encourage his own kid (if he plans to have with his boyfriend) to experiment drugs and feel the fun he’s experienced. But he should know his selfish self indulgence can kill someone.

  4. Barbls

    You took everything Adam said out of context and used it against him. Get a life and stop bashing of Adam. He is the most beautiful human being and the greatest talent of our times. He is a world star and is now in Moscow about to rock at MAXIMUM. Try as you will to put Adam down no one is listening. He is so gorgeous and and uber talented, Talk up who you like, just layoff of Adam!!!

  5. Paula Adams

    It’s really funny how people who are afraid have to belittle and attack other people. Your insecurities say alot about you as a human being. Adam Lambert is all about people being the best they can be without having to ask others for permission or judgement. He believes everyone should strive to be the best they can be and be true to themselves. If you give out love and acceptance that’s exactly what you get back. If you give out hate and ignorance well…. Maybe it’s time to do a little work on yourself instead of writing crap and lies about other people. You will be a much happier person. Peace!!:)

  6. Name

    “David who??!!” Um… where have you been?!? Have you not seen everything hes done?!??! FAIL.

  7. Sam

    Dear Why…

    What do you mean David who? I suggest you check out everything he has been doing recently. He worked on his new album due out June 28th for a year and a half so has been out of the limelight, but believe me he has been very successful and had a very successful tour in 2009. He plans on doubling his tour this time around…stay tuned…

  8. Johnny Blaze

    lolz@sara.. people like you are just idiotic. perhaps someone as absent minded and without common sense as you seem to be, would make those conclusions based on what someone says, but us regular folks know better. Adam is amazing, and may God bring him much happiness and success! sara, throw yourself out of a 10 story building window to experience the feeling of free fall! It’s amazing! <3

  9. millychill1

    Sara, you dont know what you are talking about. And yes you are in the minority. Adam Lambert IS a gorgeous guy inside and out AND YOU ARE OBVIOUSLY HOMOPHOBIC INSIDE AND OUT!

  10. sandee

    he is the Greatest of our time???? Wow!!! That’s a mouthfull.

Leave A Comment