Katy Perry Is Half-Fish, Too: Let The Mermaid Battle Begin!

July 12th, 2011 // 17 Comments

Katy Perry has already shaken her tail feathers as a “Peacock” on her California Dreams tour, and now she’s taking on an entirely different sort of animal-inspired backside: that of a fish. Which would be great and all, if Lady Gaga hadn’t just announced that her long-gestating desire to be a music video mermaid wasn’t so dead in the water after all. Last night the patriotic planker tweeted a photo of herself in lavender-tressed Little Mermaid garb (planking again), ill-timed since it was right after we learned Gaga plans to go legless in the vid for her unnamed next single. See the full pic and learn more after the jump.

The newly ginger songbird already got a bit of flack from those who thought her out-there “E.T.” video was a little too close to Gaga’s “Born This Way” space oddity. This certainly won’t help, considering Gaga’s mermaid idea was made public two months ago (though apparently scrapped in favor of a more land-locked “Edge Of Glory” visual, until recently). But let’s not jump to the conclusion that Katy Perry is an idea-thieving sea witch just yet.

We’re not sure if Katy’s pic is from the set of a music video, a photo shoot, or what, and probably it was planned long before Gaga resurfaced with her deep-sea diva plans. Most likely, it’s just an unfortunate coincidence, which happens in pop culture sometimes. Surely there are worse things than an overabundance of pop stars with fish tails, right?

Just keep swimming, ladies. And don’t make us bring in Hans Christian Anderson to settle this.


  1. Yaya

    Who cares? I mean I personally can’t stand Katy Perry but everyone is always looking to point the finger at someone about something..and you know what?? all this crap has been done before and it will always get recycled by someone else 10 years later…guess WHAT?! 10 -20 years from now when there is a “new” pop artist, their fans are gonna say how original, new, and fresh they are and that Gaga and Katy are old hags as they do to Madonna now and you’ll be saying “what do those young kids know”.. just you wait! :)

  2. Mermaid Gaga vs Mermaid Katy. Deep Impact vs. Armageddon. Antz vs. A Bug’s Life. Those two Truman Capote movies that came out the same year. Happens all the time!

  3. Michael GM

    Katy Perry is a hack. Nothing about her is original. If it wasn’t for her producers she would still be singing unsellable christian rock. She already copied the alien theme from Gaga.. I am sure she’ll be on a Motorcycle soon too.

  4. Angelica Marc

    Katy loser. She is a thief. She stole from gaga a bunch to times like with the alien, mermaid, and she even did a cover of born this way. I dont hate Katy but she aint original as Gaga.

  5. Well, She didn’t actually Copy The alien theme for Gaga. The song was called E.T. And The album came out Summer Last Year Soo.. Just Bringing that Up.
    And Gaga wasnt the First Person to Chanel her inner Mermaid, it was Ke$ha. in her Your love is my drug video She Got Turned into a Mermaid out of Dizzyness. Soo..

  6. Drayke

    Amen to that! I love Gaga and really don’t care for Katy Perry, but these types of copycat accusations are so ridiculous and petty. I really wish Laurieann Gibson hadn’t already taken a jab at Katy for this. I love her but I’m sick of her gaffes that draw Gaga’s name into petty arguments.

  7. Nyan

    Katy didn’t copy anything from the Born This Way video… What do you expect from a song called E.T.? Anyway, I don’t know whether or not this is a coincidence or just plain copying but things like this have happened in the past between Katy and Gaga, so I’ll just let it blow over…

  8. Justin M.

    Amen to what Nyan said! I still don’t understand why people complain that Katy’s ET was a rip off of Gaga’s Born This Way. Both took place in space. That was the only similarity! To be honest I’m way more excited for Katy as a mermaid than Gaga. Gaga’s look has grown a little too bizarre for my taste….it’s not innovative anymore . . ..it’s just weird and completely unnatractive. I’m still 100% entertained by Katy’s recent music videos, especially Last Friday Night! Gaga on the other hand . . well, the last few videos have been dissapointments in my book. Since when has anyone wanted to see Gaga give birth to weird space creatures and dance in a tub with Judas, Christ, and a 6 pack of beer?
    Go Katy the Mermaid!

  9. asu

    okay u don’t understand
    katy perry is just a bubblegum pop singer
    whereas gaga is a musician who has meanings behind her songs

    gaga is kubrick and katy perry is james cameron
    only one of them is a true artist – and its not katy perry

  10. Justin M.

    Totally agreed. Katy Perry’s ‘Teenage Dream’ is extremely shallow in comparison to Gaga’s ‘Born This Way.’ Gaga’s music has a real purpose which I think is wonderful and most definately defines her as a true musician. I’m just personally not a fan of her recent disturbing, bizarre, over the the top, and controversial music videos and image. She changes her look almost daily from weird…to more weird and more unnatractive! The blue armpit hair was the final draw for me! Yikes!!
    Katy does everything in a hilariously cute tongue in cheek manner . . . I think her take on a mermaid will be thoroughly entertaining! Gaga’s, however, will most likely disturb me.
    But . . that’s just my opinion. You’re more than happy to have your own :)

  11. sophie

    how can people say katy perry copied the alien theme they must of got filmed around the same time and it was quite clear katy was going to be an alien.. the song was called ET for christ sake. “little monsters” need to calm down the mermaid idea was actually Madonnas idea like a lot of gagas ideas. she is the copy so stfu :-)

  12. i normally hate to be included in ‘copycat scandals’ but this is just too obvious. common Katy, do a little research at least before accepting your management’s video treatment ideas. Gaga has been bringing up Mermaid forEVER on her twitter and in interviews and performances. As for her ET video-that was a coincidence. but THIS…..isnt.

  13. JKey

    How I hate you gaga fans.
    Always accusing everybody of coping your “super original goddess”.
    Wake up already! nobody really think gaga is original. She just copies as everybody.
    Read SOMETHING about Madonna and you will see.
    And ET video was NOT a copy. What was it supposed to be about? Cows?

  14. who is this freaking idiot? isn’t this the same ripoff artist that admitted to ripping off Madonna? and said (((she should be bitter because I did it on purpose, and you can quote me. I did it on purpose because for all those kids who believe that you can’t, I wanted to let them feel that you can. And that’s what I represent, that’s what Gags represents. That’s what this movement represents)) and she has the nerve now to say this? she should have no problem with others stealing ideas what a freaking hypocrite! she doesn’t like it when the shoes on the other foot it seems like? and who the hell is she? she didn’t invent mermaids! and besides Madonna already did mermaid in her cherish videos so if anything this is just another thing gaga can add to her list of things she steals from Madonna..this Laurieann Gibson got some nerve to say this when she represents the biggest ripoff con artist in the world!

  15. i think its pay back for among everything and everyone else that gaga copied/ripoff? and for making an alien theme video for born this way that had nothing to do with aliens..when Katy clearly had that idea for her song ET probably months b4

  16. mia

    Oh Fans stop BSing so what, if its katy or gaga or Kesha or whatever it is, sometimes people have their own ideas just sometimes things happen and it seems similar. People are always accusing other people about copying etc, meanwhile they dont realize people can be original and yet slightly the same. God Eventually brittneys going to do it and whatever other teen popstar artist will do it too. so get over yourselves and let this go already geeze.

    Nothing special peoples been doing the mermaid/alien/sex goddess bit for years- youtube/google it if you dont believe me.

  17. Hi

    Well, I basically don’t think Katy copied Gaga in the E.T music video, but its just too obvious that Katy copied the mermaid idea,she had been copied everything from Gaga since last year, her swimsuit costume, her idea trying to chg her song into uncomfortable acoustic version during performance lyk Gaga which was way too AMAZING!, the Katy Beth Perry,sex scene in music video, EVERYTHING! And always trying to act wild lyk Gaga, (And the most important: SHE DIDN’T DID THOSE BEFORE GAGA APPEARED!)

Leave A Comment