Archive for the ‘Idolator’s American Idolatry’ Category

‘American Idol’: Scotty McCreery Has Got A Friend In Carole King

April 28th, 2011 // 1 Comment

Who cares about The Voice, amiright, Idol loyalists? Although NBC’s rival singing competition premiered to stellar ratings and mostly positive reviews (including from us!), we won’t give up on American Idol just yet. Besides, there are six people left in the competition — two country singers, a rock/metal fan, a Gospel soul singer, a jazz enthusiast, and whatever you consider Haley Reinhart to be. Instead of grouping last night crop of performances into categories of Good, Okay and Bad this week, we’ve just ranked our favorites from Blarg to Best. Jump below and see if you agree who benefited the most from Carole King theme week. More »

‘American Idol’ Power List: Haley Powers Past Lauren

April 22nd, 2011 // 5 Comments

Stefano Langone’s elimination from American Idol didn’t much change the Idol Power List this week, since Stefano had been dangling at the very bottom for awhile. (Let’s just say our mouths were not hanging agape when we heard he was voted off.) After the jump, find out where the six contestants left in the competition fall on this week’s Idol Power List. More »

‘American Idol’: Stefano Says Goodbye As Katy Perry, Kanye West & David Cook Perform

April 22nd, 2011 // 4 Comments

Oh, Stefano Langone. We didn’t know you, then we fell in love with you during your powerful wild-card rendition of “I Need You Now” which got you saved by the judges… and then we became indifferent after realizing that amazing performance was a fluke. So we’re not surprised to see you voted off American Idol. But we are a little disappointed you weren’t able to give us another shining moment. More from last night’s results show, including performances by David Cook, Katy Perry and Kanye West, after the jump.
More »

‘American Idol’: Haley Reinhart Is A 21st Century Girl

April 21st, 2011 // 7 Comments

On last night’s American Idol, the Top 7 hopefuls sang songs from the 21st century, ie, everything from 2001 on. (No, the year 2000 is not part of the 21st century, so I hope you weren’t holding out for Scotty McCreery to perform Destiny’s Child’s “Say My Name”.) With literally an entire decade of songs to choose from, the contestants did not disappoint in picking some of the weirdest, most obscure songs yet. Or should we just feel grateful all seven Idols didn’t bust out yet another version of “Hallelujah”? Recap below.
More »

‘American Idol’ Power List: James Durbin & Scotty McCreery Are Riding High

April 15th, 2011 // 8 Comments

Grab a kleenex and say good riddance—er, we mean farewell—to American Idol Season 10′s floral-friendly Nashville crooner Paul McDonald, who was voted off the show after tanking on movie night. His departure doesn’t really affect our weekly Idol Power List, though, since he was dead last on it last week. Head below to see how the remaining seven contestants ranked, post-Paul.
More »

‘American Idol’: Rihanna, Kelly Clarkson & Jason Aldean Perform, Paul McDonald Says Adios

April 15th, 2011 // 1 Comment

With her current single “S&M” still riding high and the song’s Britney Spears-featuring remix looking to make a big splash on the charts next week (it’s been the top download at iTunes for the past three days), Rihanna stepped onto the American Idol stage during Thursday night’s results show to perform Loud ballad “California King Bed.” Maybe the sight of a kinder, gentler Ri Ri eased the blow of elimination for Paul McDonald, the first guy to be voted off since the Top 12 was formed.
More »

‘American Idol’: James Durbin Roars With Heavy Metal On Movie Night

April 14th, 2011 // 6 Comments

The remaining eight contestants on American Idol showed their cinematic flair last night by taking on songs from movie soundtracks. Like last week, will.i.am was back at Season 10 mentor Jimmy Iovine’s side (making it his fourth appearance on Idol in the past month). And James Durbin pretty much tore the roof off the stage by bringing a whole lot of heavy metal thunder. Read on!
More »

Pia Toscano Gets A Record Deal — So What’s The Point Of Winning ‘Idol’?

April 11th, 2011 // 4 Comments

Us Magazine reports that Pia Toscano has already signed a record deal, just a few days after being eliminated from American Idol. And she didn’t sign a record deal with just anyone — the 22-year old struck a deal with Jimmy Iovine and Interscope. You know, the same label that signs the eventual winner of Idol. Did they just give away the show’s main prize?

More »

‘American Idol’ Power List: Scotty McCreery Playing Catch Up

April 8th, 2011 // 8 Comments

If Pia Toscano hadn’t been eliminated last night on American Idol, the raven-haired balladeer would have continued to be in first place on our Idol Power List with 43 points (44, with one point deducted for being in the Bottom Three). You can leave with your head held high, Ms. Toscano! So, who usurped Pia’s crown to become the top contestant of Season 10? Find out below!

More »

Poll: Who’s Given Us The Most Shocking ‘American Idol’ Moment?

April 8th, 2011 // 33 Comments

Oh, American Idol–you wicked, wicked beast. We’re literally still reeling and crying into our Corn Flakes over the scandalous, far-too-soon exit of our Season 10 Idol Power List fave Pia Toscano from the show. But she’s hardly the only upset viewers have had to endure since the series hit the air way back in 2002. Of course, the good news for Pia is that, as we’ve learned over the years, you don’t necessarily have to make it to the AI finish line to achieve great success. Head below to vote for who you think has made the most shocking exit from American Idol in the past 10 seasons.

More »