Paula Abdul, Avatar of Freedom
On a certain level, it seems ridiculous to claim that American Idol has anything to do democracy. Sure, people vote, but it's self-selecting, has costs associated with it, and seems to have more to do with interest groups and the opinions of prominent commentators than any true expression of the popular will. Then again, you could say the same thing about presidential elections. If the "Idol=democracy" argument reeks of lazy journalism, maybe that's just because there's no significant restriction on culture in America, "Piss Christ" and Karen Finley aside. In places where there's a stronger governmental or social restriction on taste, it's possible that Idol-style contests can let hidden currents of public opinion bubble to the surface. Like, say, in Afghanistan. More »







