NEW YORK, 3:49 PM, SUN NOV 23 | 1 POSTS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS | tips@idolator.com | SUBMIT A TIP | RSS

Posts Tagged “jim derogatis”

they get letters

Jonas Brothers Fans Take Their Campaign Of Terrorizing Critics To Chicago

On Sunday, Jim DeRogatis penned an overview of the Jonas Brothers' rise to stardom that not only called the Disney-peddled pop trio "goobers," it claimed that the lyrics on "BB Good" "could just as well be dialog from a date rape as the prelude to an innocent teen make-out session" and said that the Nickelodeon boy band the Naked Brothers "beat [the JoBros] any day." You probably know what happened next: a 43-comment freakout and many, many e-mails, some of which DeRogatis was helpful enough to repost today. More »

family affair

Shady And Confused Witnesses Piss Reasonable Doubt All Over R. Kelly Trial

Man, I feel sorry for the prosecution in the R. Kelly trial. They've got three family members of the victim who swear she's in the sex tape, while the defense has three that swear she isn't. And she swears she isn't. And the hairbraider with tales of freaky three-ways between Kells and the victim? The defense has a witness who claims her fiance said she'd change her testimony for $350,000. Can the defense witnesses be trusted? Does it matter? Not being able to get the alleged victim or half her family to admit she's on the tape seems like it could leave some reasonable doubt for a jury that didn't know the victim back when the trysts were allegedly videotaped. Meanwhile, The Sun-Times has published an interview between the excused-from-testifying Jim DeRogatis and Stephanie "Sparkle" Edwards that occurred six years ago, around the time they both first saw the infamous tape. DeRo's queries are oddly riddled with multiple question marks, but Sparkle still does a good job painting a portrait of a total creep. More »

Update Judge Vincent Gaughan ruled that Chicago Sun-Times music writer Jim DeRogatis will not have to testify in the R. Kelly trial because of the Fifth Amendment, which protects people from self-incrimination, after DeRogatis showed up in court this morning to be questioned by the judge. Sun-Times attorney Damon Dunn said that an overly zealous prosecutor could potentially take any testimony in which DeRogatis admits to watching or possessing the tape and use it as the grounds for a child pornography case, and that DeRogatis is still protected under the First Amendment, despite the court's earlier ruling. The matter of who slipped the tape to DeRogatis in the first place still remains a mystery. [The Kelly Chronicles]

trapped in the courtroom

DeRo No-Shows R. Kelly Trial, Judge Threatens To Issue Arrest Warrant

Chicago Sun-Times music writer Jim DeRogatis did not show up at a Cook County court this morning to testify in the R. Kelly trial, despite a judge ordering his appearance and questioning on what he did with the sex tape at the heart of the trial between the time he acquired it and the time he handed it over to authorities. Sources have told the Chicago Tribune—which has been all over this aspect of the story today—that DeRogatis never received the subpoena issued to him by Cook County Judge Vincent Gaughan, although the judge has insisted that he told prosecutors and defense attorneys to let DeRo and his paper-appointed lawyer, Damon Dunn, know that they had a date this morning. DeRogatis has been threatened with arrest, although his lawyers say that he's in the clear because there's an appeal sort of pending. I say "sort of" because while it was filed, Dunn and his team of lawyers apparently filed it to the wrong Chicago court. (Insert joke about times being so bad for newspapers, they have to get their legal assistance from El ads here.) More »

r. kelly trial

DeRogatis Gets To Testify Like A Real Journalist

Like it or not—and barring appeals—Chicago Sun-Times pop music critic Jim DeRogatis will likely be forced to testify in the R. Kelly case. Apparently, when you turn over a tape of apparent child pornography to police, the person accused of creating said video might have a few questions for you. Strange, but true. DeRogatis and his Sun-Times lawyers have made the contention that DeRogatis' testimony would add nothing to Kelly's defense, but Judge Gaughan declared that DeRogatis would not be compelled to share his source as part of the testimony. In other news, a lawyer with a rock band approached Kelly during a break in the action—because he wanted to give Kells a demo tape. When you think it can't get stranger, this trial delivers on something even better. [Chicago Sun-Times]

On the one hand, having a contest co-sponsored by Pitchfork and Guitar Center lends support to Jim DeRogatis' "they're the new Rolling Stone!" argument. On the other hand, if you win, you get a lesson in sampler use from the RZA. (You also get a contact high at no additional charge.) While you're forbidden from entering if you work for Roland or Guitar Center, actual Wu-Tang Clan members are free to try, so this could be U-God's chance. [Pitchfork]

jumping-off-a-cliffs notes

Jim DeRogatis Takes On Ryan Schreiber, And There Are No Winners

Chicago Sun-Times critic Jim DeRogatis starts off his chat with Pitchfork head honcho Ryan Schreiber by asking if forthcoming video venture Pitchfork.TV will work off "the YouTube or YouPorn model," and things get stranger from there. Also much more argumentative! The whole q-and-a session, which is full of questions about Pitchfork's "new model" and how it affects the idea of Pitchfork as critical enterprise, whether or not Schreiber sees himself as the new Jann Wenner, and the obligatory mention of the evilness of MTV, clocks in around 3,500 words—and that's not even counting the DeRogatis-penned intro and the slightly defensive e-mail Schreiber sends along after the two signed off. After the jump a few highlights, for those of you whose "tl; dr" filter clicked on after seeing that word count. More »

live blogging?

Rock Critics Escape From Behind Keyboards Onto Late Night TV, WGA Strike Ends

Coincidence? Jim DeRogatis and Greg Kot, longtime rock critics and hosts of the "Sound Opinions" radio show, were invited onto last night's Late Night With Conan O'Brien to discuss the Grammys in lieu of a peppy young celeb, because when you want references to Kraftwerk and Robert Bly you still turn to music geeks. (But maybe I'm wrong and Hayden Panettiere and Zac Efron are big Radio-Activity fans? If so, sorry kids.) If you make it to the end, you can wonder why Conan's Jim Morrison impression wasn't just fleshed out into an entire sketch with Kot on organ and DeRo on drums. Or why he didn't at least subject them to an "If They Mated" segment. (Do they even still do that? I'm too old to make it past the 10 o'clock news.)