<![CDATA[Idolator: Plagiarism]]> http://cache.gawker.com/assets/base/img/thumbs140x140/idolator.com.png <![CDATA[Idolator: Plagiarism]]> http://idolator.com/tag/plagiarism http://idolator.com/tag/plagiarism <![CDATA["Maybe if [Avril] sang "Girlfriend" in French ... ]]> avrilll.jpg"Maybe if [Avril] sang "Girlfriend" in French the Rubinoo's wouldn't have a leg to stand on. As a Canadian she should know that humans speak many languages." [The 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, and 00s of Power Pop!]

]]>
http://idolator.com/tunes/avril-lavigne-gets-some-advice/-277201.php http://idolator.com/tunes/avril-lavigne-gets-some-advice/-277201.php Wed, 11 Jul 2007 11:21:59 EDT mjohnston http://idolator.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=277201&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[Chantal Kreviazuk Gets Off Avril Lavigne's Case]]> chantal.jpgCanadian songwriter Chantal Kreviazuk has recanted her claim that Avril Lavigne ripped off a song of hers. A statement released by Kreviazuk claimed that "Avril is an accomplished songwriter and it has been my privilege to work with her"; sadly, it didn't say what it was like to work with Dr. Luke or the Matrix. Much more interesting than Kreviazuk's backpedaling, though, was the closing line of Billboard's writeup: "Both acts are managed by Nettwerk Management in Vancouver." We're sure that was a fun conference call.

Kreviazuk Retracts Lavigne Songwriting Comments [Billboard]

]]>
http://idolator.com/tunes/plagiarism/chantal-kreviazuk-gets-off-avril-lavignes-case-276833.php http://idolator.com/tunes/plagiarism/chantal-kreviazuk-gets-off-avril-lavignes-case-276833.php Tue, 10 Jul 2007 15:15:50 EDT mjohnston http://idolator.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=276833&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[Avril Lavigne's "Influences" Keep Popping Up All Over The Place]]>
Above, a side-by-side comparison of Peaches' "I'm The Kinda" and Avril Lavigne's "I Don't Have To Try," the latest bit of semi-plagiarism to be unearthed on The Best Damn Thing. Give Avril credit: At least she's trying to adhere to Can-Con regulations in her song-borrowing.

Video Peaches And Avril Lavigne's Songs [Daily Motion] ]]>
http://idolator.com/tunes/plagiarism/avril-lavignes-influences-keep-popping-up-all-over-the-place-276684.php http://idolator.com/tunes/plagiarism/avril-lavignes-influences-keep-popping-up-all-over-the-place-276684.php Tue, 10 Jul 2007 10:30:30 EDT mjohnston http://idolator.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=276684&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[All That Vitamin Water Cash Can't Buy 50 Cent An Original Beat]]> fiveoh.jpegOver the weekend, 50 Cent released "I Got Money," which, on first listen, we actually sort of enjoyed; its halfway-decent beat was only marred by 50's lackadaisical flow (and apparently contract-mandated Vitamin Water mentions). As it turns out—and why are we not surprised by this?—said beat wasn't 50's at all, but instead nicked from a Massachusetts rapper named Jimmie Hoffa. Nah Right weighs in:

You may recall the minor controversy that arose after 50 released Amusement Park and people immediately recognized the beat from the Jim Jones/DJ Drama mixtape 7 Day Theory that dropped earlier this year. Beatjacking allegations started to fly and the producer behind the beat, Chris Styles, came forward to say that he did not sell the beat twice and that he had no idea where Jimmy got it from.
Well, don't look now, but it looks like somebody went and slipped Curtis another second hand beat. As noted by my man Bfred in a comment on YN's latest blog post, the track Curt used on his new street single I get Money, sounds pretty much identical to a track of the same name from a Massachusetts based artist named Jimmie Hoffa. Damn Curtis, all that Vitamin Water paper you're getting and you can't do due diligence on a beat? Somebody get Sha Money XL on the phone...

You can hear the original "I Got Money" at Jimmie's MySpace page, and the 50 version at HHNLive; how this news will affect the already-delayed release date of 50's forthcoming album Curtis isn't quite certain, although between this and the forgotten lyrics incident, maybe it's best for 50 to start fresh. He could even go the Fergie route and team up with his favorite sports-energy drink!

Curtis = Still Jacking for Beats [Nah Right]
Jimmie Hoffa [MySpace]

]]>
http://idolator.com/tunes/plagiarism/all-that-vitamin-water-cash-cant-buy-50-cent-an-original-beat-274419.php http://idolator.com/tunes/plagiarism/all-that-vitamin-water-cash-cant-buy-50-cent-an-original-beat-274419.php Mon, 02 Jul 2007 16:17:03 EDT mjohnston http://idolator.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=274419&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[Will The Real "Creep" Please Stand Up?]]> As long-time readers and admirers of My Old Kentucky Blog, we were distressed to receive a tip in our inbox, claiming the site lifted significant portions of the Wikipedia entry on Radiohead's "Creep", without giving any credit to the fine, fine nerds who work on Wikipedia. After checking it out, it looks like MOKB jacked not just a few little facts or figures, but entire paragraph-length passages (again, without crediting Wiki). What the hell's wrong with you kids? How hard is it to write 800 original words about Radiohead? That's the only band you ever talk about.

UPDATE: MOKB posted a note this evening: "It appears I am facing expulsion from Blog U. I've lost my scholarship for sure and am likely to end up down the street at the local Junior Blog college. I apologize to all parties involved for the heinous plagerization of Wikipedia on my Term Blog Post Paper."

No worries, MOKB. As we noted in the intro, you're one of our favorites. MOKB also notes that Gerard vs. Bear had this "story" hours before we did, but frankly, we were too busy making Clay Aiken jokes to notice. Now that we mention it, can we all just get back to making Clay Aiken jokes? It's what we're best at.

Click through to find three examples of suspiciously close "Creep" critiques.

EXAMPLE 1
From Wikipedia's "Creep" entry, last modified Sept. 22, 2006:

"Creep" was the first single (not counting the Drill EP) from the English rock band Radiohead, and a track on their 1993 debut album Pablo Honey. When it was first given limited release in September 1992, Radio 1 found it too depressing, and so after being aired only twice, it was taken off the station's playlist, but it subsequently became the band's biggest hit.

From today's MOKB post on "Creep":

Creep is widely considered the song that launched Radiohead into the world music spotlight. It was their first single from their 1993 album Pablo Honey. When it was first given limited release in September 1992, Radio 1 found it too depressing, and so after being aired only twice, it was taken off the station's playlist.

EXAMPLE 2

From Wiki:

The single is generally credited with catapulting the band to world-wide renown. In late March 1993 they flew to Israel for their first taste of fame following its success there as a result of heavy airplay on Galei Tzahal, and late in May they flew to the USA for more success— a San Francisco radio station had picked it up, and little by little "Creep" had permeated the nation's airwaves.

From MOKB:

In late March 1993 they flew to Israel for their first taste of fame following its success there as a result of heavy airplay on Galei Tzahal, and late in May they flew to the USA as a San Francisco radio station had picked it up, and little by little "Creep permeated the nation's airwaves. It did not become a in the UK until September of that year almost a year after it's official release.

EXAMPLE 3

From Wiki:

Thom Yorke explains the song saying that he wrote it while studying at Exeter University. It tells the tale of an inebriated man who tries to get the attention of a woman he is attracted to, by following her around. In the end, he lacks the self-confidence to pull it off. Although he usually referred to the drunken student in the third person, with no little contempt, sometimes outright denying it was him, he sometimes admitted it was.

From MOKB:

Thom Yorke explains the song saying that he wrote it while studying at Exeter University. It tells the tale of an inebriated man who tries to get the attention of a woman he is attracted to, by following her around. In the end, he lacks the self-confidence to pull it off. Although he usually referred to the drunken student in the third person, with no little contempt, sometimes outright denying it was him, he sometimes admitted it was.

There's not enough bold-faced fonts in the world for that last paragraph.

Creep (song) [Wikipedia]
MOKB Covers Project Redux: Creep [My Old Kentucky Blog]

]]>
http://idolator.com/tunes/blogs/will-the-real-creep-please-stand-up-203426.php http://idolator.com/tunes/blogs/will-the-real-creep-please-stand-up-203426.php Tue, 26 Sep 2006 18:00:05 EDT Brian Raftery http://idolator.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=203426&view=rss&microfeed=true