Idolator

Well, it's not the Virgin Mary appearing in a grilled cheese, but we're betting that this "Antonella Barba toast" (you can tell it's her by the big grin) will go down a lot better than her performance of "Because You Love Me" last week did—even if Barba's image was rendered with a Sharpie. Bidding closes in 15 hours and change, so you'd better hurry.

Antonella Barba's Picture on toast, American idol rare [eBay, via VH1]