Idolator

So does the lead guy need the money for beer or for rehab?

I kind of like it?

Leave it to the guest blogger to make a Zelda reference...

I think it's fantastic.

This isn't nearly as bad as some of the others in the race. I'm rather keen on the font.

Tis Cthulu's head, he's riding a bad star to rock stardom!

yeah, the only thing wrong with this cover is that it's being considered one of the worst.

i mean, have we forgotten about the 8-bit digital kaleidoscopic vomit that is MIA's album cover?

Right, from a graphic design standpoint, there's absolutely nothing wrong with this cover (except maybe the slight glow on the edges of the octopus). Keane's obsession with the ocean and all things aquatic? Well, that's something else all its own.

Zelda reference... delightful.

Goon Squad reference... priceless.

I've seen worse.
I'm telling you...there had better be a gallery of these "worst cover" picks by the end of the year, so we can properly soak it all in.

Or not.

I kinda like it for the very sorta-Zelda-ness for which you slam it... The font used fits well with it too.

Not bad!

Hmm. I like it. Then again, I've been playing Kingdom of Loathing...

No, no...Keane doing a cover of Coldplay's "Clocks" would be like Christian Slater starring in a Jack Nicholson biopic...them doing U2's "With or Without You" is like Christian Slater remaking The Godfather and taking the Don Corleone role.

veruca salt reference: nice

@revmatty: Veruca Salt was originally referncing the Beatles, so basically all of rock music is a big circle jerk.

Yeah. I think you are way off on this one. The design is pretty alright. The title? Terrible.

I would have called a compilation of demos as "Before The Iron Sea" and a compilation of B-sides as "Beside The Iron Sea".

Great, now I have the Zelda theme playing in my head.