Idolator

Megadeth by a mile. The Nuge cover is not really bad at all, and could be from his heyday, aside from what would be the anachronism of the presumably unintended breast cancer awareness signifier.

I'll take Album Abominations for $1000, Alex.

I still have little idea of what that green-pink blotch on the Megadeth cover is. It sorta looks like an angel. If we're judging eyesores, the guy who got fired from Metallica wins the Lions Club scholarship.

i voted for megadeth, even though i sort of like that they've kept the same logo forever. next to all that megadeth nonsense, the love grenade cover looks almost quaint. plus, if there can be breast cancer awareness sun chips, why not breast cancer awareness grenades, too? (i can't believe i'm defending that cover....)

Sorry Uncle Ted. Be glad you have two entries this year, because Megadeth really outdid themselves with this one.

I'm so annoyed and offended at Ted Nugent for even going through the trouble of making that other cover that I voted for him. However, between these two covers there's no contest that Megadeth wins.

I really like United Abominations as an album, but certainly not that cover. It got my vote.

I love the Megadeath cover in all its overabundant glory.

On to the next round they go.

Superb album, super-crappy cover. Deth!

megadeth is ugly as hell, but fighting breast cancer with hand grenades wins my vote for nugent.

Hurrah, I'm the nameless commentator! Anyway, I can't help myself from voting based on musical quality.