Idolator

The Primal Scream track would be a decent instrumental, but Kate Moss sounds like Joan Jett with laryngitis. Or like a Tri Delt singing into a brush in the sorority house bathroom, imitating Joan Jett with laryngitis.

The Slowdive is good as well, but Lydia Lunch always wins the award in the batshit weird category. The singing on the verse sounds like Divine getting a prostate exam.

Can I anti-vote for the Primal Scream one and let the others tie?

Also, there's at least one good black metal cover version from the mid-nineties I've heard...

I think whenver you combine Kate Moss with music, you get a trainwreck. Look at how things are with her (ex?) boyfriend.

I vote for Firewater with Britta Phillips...really spooky and lovely duet.

Forget this - if we're doing songs by Nancy S., why not compare versions of "Bang Bang (My Baby Shot Me Down)"? Nancy vs. Cher vs. Vanilla Fudge vs. Petula Clark vs. Jack White?

Note to Kate Moss: Doing lines does not automatically make you a rock superstar.

seeing as it's a duet, shouldn't you acknowledge rowland s. howard as lydia lunch's singing partner, as he's clearly credited on the record itself?

The Vanilla Fudge version of "Velvet" is sweet!!