Idolator

Glad you're curious. But I think the answer is going to be pretty clearly Jellyfish. If there was ever a poll to end up 100% to 0% it will be this one. (Though I have to say the new version isn't bad at all.)

Jason Falkner revival! I see he has a new record out this summer.

I was talking to a friend who had had extensive contact with Manning and he said Roger and Andy still "hated" each other. So I predict a tour in two years.

I do like how the arrangement changed not a whit on the McFries versh. Why mess with perfection, etc?

I've heard worse covers, but really, Jellyfish is one of those bands that just shouldn't be covered. Especially note-for-note.

Perfection, indeed.

I can't believe a "British boy band" is having a hit with this song.

Andy Sturmer's music may be scarce on the charts here, but he's doing just fine in Japan, as Puffy AmiYumi's numero-uno songwriter. And his genius in that department has been pretty damn amazing-- particularly in figuring out how to appropriate every major American musical prototype, almost note for note, and tweak it for Japanese teenage girls.

Talk about not messing with the original: I like how the cover, even though it's by a bunch of Brits, keeps in the line about "If I had a dollar..."

The cover itself is fine... however, DON'T go searching for any pictures or video of McFly. I should've let well enough alone and moved on with my day, but my curiosity got peaked and I YouTube'd them -- Gasp.

Now I've got a huge crack in my monitor screen where I hit it... with my face... 7 times.

Six people voted for McFly? Is that by accident?

I had the misfortune to watch Just My Luck and I can't quite remember what was worse: Lindsay Lohan's constant--CONSTANT--shrieking or McFly's "music".

Some peppy lads, that McFly. Nice try. I see an energy drink commercial in their future.

Wow, way to add nothing whatsoever to that song. What the heck ever happened to Jellyfish anyway?