We were pretty excited when we heard that My Chemical Romance was set to play Saturday Night Live—but alas, their performance on Saturday's show was somewhat lacking. Playing in the audienceless vacuum that is the SNL set didn't help matters, but picking the downtempo "Cancer" as their second song proved to be their downfall—if any band should not go the traditional rocker-then-ballad singles-release route, it's these guys, who derive about 90% of their strength from speeding up, and turning up, the most over-the-top aspects of rock and roll.
SNL - MCR: Cancer [YouTube]
SNL - MCR: Welcome To The Black Parade [YouTube]
Previously: Idolator's Breathless Anticipation Of My Chemical Romance's The Black Parade





Comments
Nice Barbara Barrie 'do, Freddie Mercury-lite boy.
I couldn't agree more. When I saw them come out on stools for the second song, I knew that there would be no fist pumping, rock-star posing, lets-change-the-world-with-rock-and-roll statements being made. That is what I came to see, and that is why I am getting excited about this band.
i have gone from being completely ambivalent about black parade to totally loving it in about three days. this performance was a let down, but doesn't change my love for the album.
for my money, the best musical performance on this ep. was the will ferrell/john c reilly (aka sean c reilly) duet.
'I'm soggy from the chemo' , what a line.
Okay, I'm starting to come around on this band. Slowly, ever so slowly, like a turtle peaking his head out for the first time after an owl attack.
Based on all the interviews, these guys inexplicably believe that "Cancer" is, quite literally, one of the best songs ever.
They have, on more than one occasion, called it "difficult to listen to" (in the too-emotional sense, not the sounds-awful sense).
This is rather disappointing, especially since there are so many better songs on the album (namely, every other song on the album).
One thing to look forward to- they recorded two videos simultaneously a couple months ago, one for "Welcome to the Black Parade," and one for some other song ("House of Wolves," I think). During the filming of the second video, so many of the band members were injured that there were rumors that they got in a car accident.
Apparently the video is basically them playing the song in front of a wall of fire, and they all went nuts. The drummer got seriously burned on his leg, and the rest of the band basically just collided/tackled/destroyed each other. So, that should be fun to watch when it is released.
The missuz and I love these guys and especially the new hit, and so we plunked down to watch this all excited.
But the moment we felt let down was when Gerard couldn't hit the high note on the chorus. Seriously, this is not a small matter - the whole key to the song's greatness is that note he hits on "We'll CAR-ry on!!" and he totally dumped it.
I'm with joe bananas that this doesn't dim my appreciation for the song (or, potentially, the album) much, but it definitely tarnishes it a bit. Then again, Kelly Clarkson couldn't really hit all the notes on the immortal "Since U Been Gone" when she was on SNL. Damn you, ProTools!
Are all of Ultragrrrl's acts required to wear gay Sgt. Pepper outfits now?
Emo has finally gone SO gay we have a bleached Freddie Mercury crying about chemo.
But I like it. Does that make me gay? Or just emo?
gaymo
I'm with everyone else. I dont know if I should be hating myself for liking the new MCR album or just enjoy it and keep myself away from sharp objects.
I'm loving the album, mostly "teenagers."
But "cancer" is the one song that makes me alternate between snickering at the lyrics and thinking "wow, I'm like 15 years old to be into this band and not be ashamed of myself."
Seriously, I cant stop playing "Teenagers" at high volume. Yeah, it is derivative of T-rex and glam in general. But a lot of people have tried to imitate T-Rex and none of them sound that good doing it.
"15 years TOO old" d'oh
.....SNL's long been famous for humbling hit bands. I don't know if it's the room, sabotage, or just the band being tight, but often the worst performance of any band is when they're on SNL. My vote for absolute worst was when the Rolling Stones "Beast of Burden" back in the 1970s. Horrid.
.....I'd rather hear missed notes than anyone pulling an Ashlee, though!
Comment on this post
Reply by EmailLogin with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?