This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already) - Idolator Comments

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Manola — Thu, 15 May 2008 21:52:57 EDT

I loved everything about Fantasia's performance. This is what I've been dying to see for the last 4 months: distinctive vocals + solid music + dancing + energy + the element of surprise. She had it all, she's always had this in-your-face attitude where it looks she doesn't give a damn who's in the audience, she does her thing and move on. Brilliant!

Manola

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

punkybunky — Thu, 15 May 2008 17:22:27 EDT

I've never been a fan of Fantasia's Macy-Gray-accidentally-put-her-hand-on-a-hot-iron wailing, but she kinda rocked it last night. She gets points alone for having more energy than the three finalists put together, through nine songs, had on Tuesday night. But what really made it was Simon's WTF?! expression. Leona Lewis, she is not.

Notice how Ryan didn't even ask the judges what they thought afterwards? I thought they usually did that when former contestants came back to perform.

punkybunky

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Bob Loblaw — Thu, 15 May 2008 15:07:50 EDT

@Tauwan: Agreed that it was ballsy, so points for that, and I'm all for a treacle moratorium. But I can't tell if you're saying it was awesome-good or awesome-trainwreck, because I can only cosign on the latter.

Bob Loblaw

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

sicksteanein — Thu, 15 May 2008 14:27:35 EDT

@VivaLaMainstream: How about a futuristic performance of Livin' on a prayer with a faux vinyl intro and a beatbox vs. drummer showdown?

sicksteanein

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

cassidy2099 — Thu, 15 May 2008 14:10:04 EDT

@Tauwan: Holla

@tubby: Actually it was "One Big Holiday" from It Still Moves.

cassidy2099

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Tauwan — Thu, 15 May 2008 12:51:09 EDT

@Bob Loblaw:

Nuh uh uh. Not so fast. That performance was on point. here's why:

(1) She could have easily sung some treacly ballad or roped it all in. She didn't.
(2) That hair.
(3) That form fitting -velour?- and shimmering pants suit.
(4) The background dancers.
(5) Did she almost make her "knees touch her elbows" on the American Idol stage? Yes, yes she did.
(6) Simon's face throughout the performance.
(7) The bewildered "what should I do to this" look of the young ladies in the audience during her performance.
(8) The song ending choreography with her back up dancers. Complete with points to the Lord and exits Stage Left.
(9) For doing what the producers wanted Syesha to do with that Happy Feet song.
(10)(10) And finally, for once again bucking the trend and giving the Idol audience less Whitney/Mariah, and more Janis/Tina/Mary J. That's what's up.

I mean COME ON! And Fantasia and She who fronts that group of live action Bratz dolls masquerading as full fledged entertainers should never be mentioned in the same breath. Just saying.

Tauwan

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Maura Johnston — Thu, 15 May 2008 12:42:06 EDT

@Bob Loblaw: "Scherzinger-starring-in-a-Caligula-remake-directed-by-Brett-Ratner"

i disagree with you (i want to hear the song on record) but WOW. that image.

Maura Johnston

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Bob Loblaw — Thu, 15 May 2008 12:37:21 EDT

OH COME ON! The LL Cool J ringer whose mic went out halfway through his verse? The cheesy funk-lite production values? The unsexy, all over the place vocals?

It was an orgy of bad taste. Epic, Scherzinger-starring-in-a-Caligula-remake-directed-by-Brett-Ratner bad taste.

Bob Loblaw

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

VivaLaMainstream — Thu, 15 May 2008 12:21:20 EDT

@tubby: While far be it for me to bash either David Cook or Bon Jovi, things that shouldn't happen ever again include an ACOUSTIC version of Livin' On A Prayer.

==TJ==

VivaLaMainstream

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

tubby — Thu, 15 May 2008 10:50:53 EDT

@saturn: Yup, it was MMJ. I think it was something off Z. At least someone involved with the show has heard of music recorded in this decade. Of course cut to David Cook and Bon Jovi is playing. Though I'll never complain about the Jov.

tubby

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

VivaLaMainstream — Thu, 15 May 2008 10:22:01 EDT

Fantasia last night=(Mary J Blige + P!nk + Janis Joplin)- Sexy

==TJ==

VivaLaMainstream

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

saturn — Thu, 15 May 2008 10:21:57 EDT

I'm catching up with the show via youtube. Was that My Morning Jacket being played during David A's homecoming film? It would be cool if David A was asked to sing MMJ- it's actually in his range.

Also, David Cook singing "Ain't No Stopping Us Now" sounded a lot like Michael McDonald. Maybe he'll get some of the granny vote after all.

saturn

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Chris Molanphy — Thu, 15 May 2008 10:00:31 EDT

I expect critics to pile on the Fantasia performance today (the usually reliable Craig Berman at MSNBC already has), but I'm with you - I thought it was a cool hard-R&B song that didn't sound great live but makes a killer pop recording. Will be interesting to see what kind of iTunes business it does over the next week.

Chris Molanphy

This Year, "American Idol" Will Be Won By A Dude Named David (But You Knew That Already)

Jerkwheat — Thu, 15 May 2008 09:30:01 EDT

HA! Simon's face during Fantasia - I think we rewound to watch it again at least five times last night.

Jerkwheat